[Galadriel55]

Nerwen shall be first.

Originally Posted by Nerwen

*coughing fit* You know, I don't think this is quite the time to be critiquing another actor's, er, talents, do you?

In response to Bom talking about Gifteds.

Then she disappers for the rest of the Day.

Day 2

Her opinion on the votes:

Originally Posted by Nerwen

Steve gave no reason; G55 voted Sally as a "submarine". That's common enough for emergency votes– but indeed, you'd think people who were simply trying save a claimed gifted would go for someone else who already had votes. I suppose they might have lost track, though.

EDIT:X'd with G55.
EDIT2: Correction: Steve voted for Sally, and G55 for Eruhen, both as "submarines".

Then this post:

Originally Posted by Nerwen

Back again. Sorry for not being around– I just wasn't able to get to a computer for most of the day.


This is true– through a frame can't be ruled out either. Still, I think it's pretty safe to assume that *if* the wolves in fact killed him for being "Seer-ish" it would have been because of his comments on one of those two.


Why, though? G55's last post looks quite bad to me, actually.

EDIT:X'd with Eruhen.

After this she questions Eruhen for a few posts, before voting him:

Originally Posted by Nerwen

Eruhen, I believe this is your first game, so sorry if this is all just you trying to get the hang of things. All the same, the amount of backtracking and seeming evasiveness in your recent posting really does not look good.

Day 3

... is mostly spent arguing against Eomer and trying to prove that she is the Seer, and then votes for him.

While Nerwen never directly accuses anyone of wolvery and always has a careful neutral tone, she just leave any stronger evidence that would point to her as the Seer.



aaaaand Eomer!

His first posts are not very important, and anyways are undeciferable.

Originally Posted by Eomer of the Rohirrim

Seem to remember fowk latching onto Bom's, shall we say, daring playing style in the last game. He'd be a great bold wolf because now I'm thinking it's just his style.

Just a post I thought worthwhile to quote, as Bom claims Ranger...

Originally Posted by Eomer of the Rohirrim

Eh... Fitiver's gan on here will mak for some good readin' imorn. That's why I leave Bom and Boro.

There's probably a wolf who's said nothing other than character posts yet, so I'll pick one of them. Back in a minty.

Combined with this:

Originally Posted by Eomer of the Rohirrim

Sally fits the criteria (oh wow, I never find her suspicious or anything... ), as does Glirdan. I'm totally aware that I myself fit my own criteria of not adding anything to the discussion....

...until now

Sorry Glirdan, but just not enough from you today. And the first vote is always a safe one. Chances are you're a busy innocent but, because no-one else is really jumping out at me, you're acting the conservative wolf.

This being the second vote in the game, I won't put too much stress on this, but people have questioned it.

Day 2

First post:

Originally Posted by Eomer of the Rohirrim

Sorry Glirdan. Not the best choice I could have made.

And Inzil deid? The immediate thing to take from this is suspicion of McCaber and Bom.

Eonwe and G55 seem likely innocents to me. Not sure, of course. Certain others look suspicious too; I'll try to go through it in more detail later.

"The immediate thing to take from this is suspicion of McCaber and Bom" - looking for the last wolf, it seems. Though can't really be considered evidence in favour of Seering.

Originally Posted by Eomer of the Rohirrim

Interesting thought. Presuming that Boro is the Hunter, the wolves might consider him safe to leave. He's not the seer; if no-one touches him, he can't use his power. But is this ignoring the point that he's a potential known innocent? Probably better to kill off the hunter at the start of the game if you can, so it's more likely he'll have no idea who the wolves are and he'll hunt an innocent.

Yes, they might be counting on us lynching him, but this is pretty risky.

At this stage, chances of catching the Seer are not high. This means I see three options:

1. Boro is a wolf, playing us for fools.

2. Boro is innocent; wolves seriously believe Inzil is the seer.

3. Boro is innocent; wolves not sure about Inzil but, rightly or wrongly, choose to ignore Boro.

I believe option 3 suggests wolves who are not thinking very carefully. And I think it's the less likely option.

I don't see how option 1 would aid the wolves in any way. The real Hunter could appear at any moment.

Option 2 is the most likely. So we lynch one of Inzil's targets today. Bom or McCaber.

"He's not the seer" - obviously, since he claims to be the Hunter. But the sureness with which Eomer says that...?

Some posts in between, and:

Originally Posted by Eomer of the Rohirrim

++MCCABER

Because of Inzil's vote. Otherwise, I can't see why the wolves would have killed him. Willing to give Bom the benefit of the doubt for now, although would not be opposed to his lynching.

Then encourages others to follow suit, as he is curious about McC's role. And then he showers us with clues.

Originally Posted by Eomer of the Rohirrim

Don't worry, Boro. I think the Ranger is going to get a good hint today.

Originally Posted by Eomer of the Rohirrim

Eonwe, G55, Eruhen all probably innocent. I think Bom is innocent too.

Yeah, it almost feels lame doing it like this, but...

Originally Posted by Eomer of the Rohirrim

Pfft! You are suspicious when you are acting wolfish and being caught in the act by the seer.

(with Eruhen's reply - "That's certainly interesting, Eomer, especially considering how last game turned out.")

Originally Posted by Eomer of the Rohirrim

Two of them certainly are.

Again, the sureness.

Originally Posted by Eomer of the Rohirrim

Ach...

Kill Nerwen AND Shasta with fire! And then kill their ashes!

Ranger - Protect! ^^

One more post about bing curious about McC.

Day 3

Tries to uphold his status as Seer, continues accusing Nerwen and Shasta, and says Bom is the Ranger.



From here, I say Eomer is more believable.

Edit: xed since my last.