Quote:
Originally Posted by Inziladun
Most disconcerting, this. I came here to portray one who exemplified wisdom, and I shall do my best to discern the safest course of action for us. Money is nice, but for the moment I think safety is preferable.
It will be helpful if all make it a point to share their ideas, and not simply lurk in the background waiting for others to do so.
G55 seems a bit glib under the circumstances, perhaps. But then people have strange reactions sometimes to danger.
x/d with Eruhen- Unfortunately I lack the healing powers of the Lord of Imladris.
|
(Underlining mine). On hindsight, the underlined words probably screamed "Seer" to the wolves.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Inziladun
So it's that easy, then? Seems a bit too easy, rather like sending the Ring over Sea.
However, it's certainly possible we have evil ones among the first posters, excited about their work and confident.
x/d with G55
|
Nothing much here.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Inziladun
You'd be hard pressed to do so. 
Does this make Glirdy look bad for making a safe-seeming, random vote, or good for being so obvious about it? Hmm... |
The first bit referrs to finding a normal person among us (normal, not ordo
don't get excited). The second - to
Glirdy's vote. While I totall agree with his "Hmm", nothing about
Zil jumps out here, or the reson for the kill.
#55 is
Bomanalysis that I won't quote in full. The conclusion:
Quote:
Originally Posted by Inziladun
Conclusions? He seems a bit carefree and fearless if he's a wolf, but does come off as a little defensive. Then again, as I said, the force with which some have decided to go after him makes me wonder.
|
Indefinite attitude towards
Bom.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Inziladun
Thought you were leaning toward Shasta, weren't you Bom? That's changed because it's now Boro who's after you?
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by Inziladun
It isn't lost on me that Bom's vote was the second on Boro, either.
|
This has a more accusing tone.
#70 is a vote count.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Inziladun
I don't know that I want to choose between Bom and Boro on the basis of toDay. Let's go another direction.
++McCaber
He makes a very effective evil submarine, and I don't recall seeing anything from him but a couple of easy jabs at Bom.
x/d with all since #73. Well, at least the Seer's got some good leads now....
|
The vote. Quite out of the blue, considering that nothing much has been said of
McC the entire game. It is well explained, but could have alerted the wolves if
Cabbie is one of them - he wasn't the only submarine.
However, the last part points against my earlier theory of wolves killing
Zil on grounds of potential Seerdom. It doesn't sound like a thing a Seer would say. However, the wolves may have thought otherwise.
So, what does this summary give us?
Zil could have been mistaken for the Seer. Or, he could have simply been a villager whose death won't point to anyone in particular, or point at a wrong direction. If it's the latter, this whole thing was pretty much pointless (but I, personally, needed to go through all the posts at least because otherwise I'd bugger myself until I do
). However, if he was really suspected of Seering,
McC and
Bom, and to some extent
Glirdy could have been the ones worried about him last Night.
I've probably done more flip-flopping on everyone and everything in this post than I've done throughout the entire previous game of WW, but I want to consider all the possibilities.
Now, having done this, I'll try to summarise yesterDay's votes (what a mess they were!). Hopefully they'll prove more helpful, or at least useful, than this summary.