[satansaloser2005]

DAY ONE

Originally Posted by A Little Green

I'm off to bed pretty much now, meaning that I get to cast the first vote of the Day! I'm not sure about this, but it being the best shot I have,

++ Bom

I think I've explained enough in my previous posts, but in short - planning to vote Sally because of her "death wish" strikes me as an idea that benefits the baddies more than us.

I do have to shake my head at this, because, to me, Bom's "suspicion" of me was a joke, and a fairly obvious one. But it was the first Day, and as I've stated somewhere else, baddies can hide behind jokes, so in the absence of having a better candidate, I could see how Greenie would do this. I still don't entirely agree with it, but I'll give it a pass (especially because she didn't vote me ).

Originally Posted by Kitanna

Thanks dear

++Sally
My hat I say!

I have to go now. Best of luck to the village for the rest of today.

We know she was an innocent, so I'll not bother to comment on this much, except to say that I'm going to eat a sock when I get home tonight.

Originally Posted by Eomer of the Rohirrim

++Galadriel55

So you'll remember me forever as the first person ever to vote for you in Werewolf. Har!

Seriously: too much defending of Sally, too much attacking Bom and a weird interpretation of Kitanna. I think there's something lupine with this one!

He'd voiced his suspicions, and backed them up with a fairly solid vote. I don't see a huge problem here.

Originally Posted by Shastanis Althreduin

++Lottie

See above for reasons.

Shasta, out.

First Lottie vote, and probably the one that got him killed.

Originally Posted by Mithalwen

OK it has been a long hot day and my head hurts, I feel I must stay with my strongest pick. I found the initial announcement odd and the complete volteface on playing style too bizarre.

++Satansaloser

I'm flipping known for this stuff. (That and my name is Sally, but meh.) As I've said to Nog before, playing style or abundance of posts does not dictate wolvery, so for that to be her strong point against me? It's definitely shaky. (I'll let this pass, however, because the post in question -of mine- was rather intended to stir up discussion, so I shan't fault people for, well, discussing it. It was also the first Day, so I get that she didn't have much to go on, especially if she wasn't feeling well.)

Originally Posted by Legate of Amon Lanc

Okay, voting now, to minimalise the mess and make votes more relevant in their reading.

++Lottie

He initially suspected Lottie because her first list was, well, rubbish. It seems a sudden case, because his list before that had Lottie as just a person he'd like to see more from, but at the same time I don't see Legate bussing a packmate when he easily could have made me his top suspect for the Day instead.

Originally Posted by Thinlómien

++LOTTIE

Sorry m'dear but you're more suspicious than Sally...


edit: xed with G55 and Legate

Erm, since when? No, I know, Lommie doesn't find me that guilty, and that's lovely, but the statement looks fishy to me. It was between me, whom she didn't even suspect, and only one other person? What about everyone else in the village? Just an observation, and possibly even a paranoid one. >.<

Originally Posted by Galadriel55

++Lommy

I still maintain that this was sort of random. If I may quote the following....

Originally Posted by Galadriel55

I could vote for Greenie, Eomer, Lommy, and possibly Nilp, but there has been limited participation from all of them.

Lommy's posts are somewhat fishy - she has no opinions well into the Day, and decides to vote for Lottie as soon as Shasta casts suspicion on her, but then decides against it. She will probably be my candidate.

Up until this, she had ONLY commented on Kit and Bom. They were her suspects, they were the baddies. Then Lommie is suddenly evil for not having much of an opinion. It just looks strange to me. Also, notice that her "I could vote for" list included neither of the people she was up against until just previously in the thread.

Originally Posted by Nogrod

I see this has been decided while I was writing my last post. Let's check it.

++ Loslote

This looks so bad. "I see this has been decided," he says. So because it's been decided, he wants to just go along with it? It bothers me a lot. Like, a lot a lot.

Originally Posted by Nilpaurion Felagund

++Nilpaurion Felagund

There's my boy.

Originally Posted by satansaloser2005

++Galadriel

Erm....that's my vote. Hi there. *waves*



DAY TWO

Originally Posted by Eomer of the Rohirrim

Will probably be around later but there's a chance I'll have no internet access whatsoever, so I'll vote now.

++Galadriel55

Was suspicious of her yesterday, and she looks more suspicious with every post. Not certain she's guilty or anything but she is my top suspect.

Interested in seeing Kitanna's comeback on Lommy, which I'm pretty sure will have to be toned down as it seems to rest on a misinterpretation.

Sally still suspicious. Wondering about Nerwen, Mithalwen and Nilp.

Hopefully (probably) back later.

At least he's consistent? :/

Originally Posted by A Little Green

Bed-time.

++ Eomer

She laid off Bom in a previous post, and now seems to be voting Eomer because (a few posts back) she describes him as confusing. I'm not liking this.

Originally Posted by Mithalwen

Nogrod, you of all people should know how I feel about last minute voting. I don't call half an hour before deadline early. Better to steer where you believe someone guilty than follow ....

Anyway the indisposition of last night means I am tired now ... same vote, same reasons - generally all over the place.

++Satansaloser

Same vote for no reasons. She didn't even try to come up with another candidate. I know she's not the seer, because she'd be all over someone else if she was, so my best guess is that she's a wolf who realizes that I'm (as always) easy enough to get rid of, and she's going to take that opportunity.

Originally Posted by Bom Tombadillo

Argh. No new developments that I've really noticed - I didn't have a chance to start my read-through at the time I planned and so had to do a rather rushed and still not-quite-complete one - just considering of Day One suspicions. Honestly, if I'm going to be this bad about time I should just drop out or something. Anyway, throwaway vote:

++Kitanna

x'ed with Mithalwen.

I flipping HATE this vote. Calling it a throwaway vote is my biggest problem here; if he just said he didn't have time, I'd be okay with it, but calling it a throwaway? :/

Originally Posted by Galadriel55

You might want to consider doing all that during the Night. Saves time.

Anyways, I think I've talked about Kit enough toDay to not have to repeat everything now. If you want clarification (*looks at Legate*) tell me so and I'll summarise my reasoning.

++Kitanna

Edit: xed with.... everything!

So now she flips back to Kitanna (the flipping here being from her vote yesterDay going in a completely different direction). Obviously we know how this worked out, but I do have to give her some credit for going back to and sticking with a suspicion, even if it was wrong. I still don't like her vote from yesterDay, however.

Originally Posted by Nogrod

Okay, I just can't wait for the 45 minutes even if I wished to. Too early a call tomorrow.

I'm getting uneasy with this, even if there are reasons staring right at my eyes there. This Kit-wagon looks like too opportunistic even if popular wagons hjave caught baddies too. But now something feels really odd in here.

++ Mith

What the heck?!?! So you suspect Kit, you think the case against her is good, but you're still not going to vote for her?

Originally Posted by Legate of Amon Lanc

++Eomer

Although to be honest, I feel now really unsure about it right when I cast it. But whatever. Decisions need to be made.

It's important to note here that he ties Eomer and Kit, which makes me strongly believe that if either of them is a wolf, the other is not. I'm leaning toward (if either of them) Legate being the wolf in the scenario here.

Originally Posted by Thinlómien

++Kitanna

Rather her than Eomer. (If she's innocent and he is not I'm going to hit somebody for making this statement, possibly myself.)


edit: xed with Kit - and sorry to hear about stressful RL, it's not fun.

I'm not comfortable with this vote either. See Legate, only in reverse. But would Lommie be that obvious?

Originally Posted by Nilpaurion Felagund

Gah. That took too long.

++Kitanna

Previous blinkly-light thing still stands.

I still think he's innocent, so I don't know. Meh.

Originally Posted by Kitanna

Be ready to hit yourself, Lommykins.


++Sally

I'll vote my real suspect

Edit: But I die innocent I say! INNOCENT! But really, good luck to the rest of the village.

*pets her*

We'll meet up and have a feast of hats. What do you say?

Originally Posted by Nerwen

Running out of time

++Kitanna.

EDIT:X'd since last post.

Again with the "she's innocent, so meh" spiel.

Originally Posted by satansaloser2005

++Kit

Bloody lack of time. More of the splainy toMorrow if I'm still around. >.<

Hello, my vote again. Moving on now....


DAY THREE

Originally Posted by A Little Green

Just my luck. I'm the only one here for over an hour, then people appear just as I'm going to bed. Anyway, I'm not at all sure about this, but since I want to base my vote on an actual logical reason instead of a vague fishy feeling I haven't havd the time to check properly, my vote will go to

++ Nogrod

I'm agreeing with some of her logic here, so I'm going to call this vote legit, but of course it's also a safe time to vote, a time when anything can happen, so it could be a show case (see what I did there?) rather than actual suspicion. I'm just trying to balance the side of me that wants to trust Greenie with the tiny part of me that's screaming that she's a wolf. Tiny, tiny part, but still. Need balance!




And I didn't even cross-post this entire time. I call shenanigans.