05-23-2011, 07:19 AM
|
#57
|
Wight
Join Date: Apr 2011
Location: Settling down in Bree for the winter.
Posts: 208
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by Galadriel55
Yes, but the way I understood blantyr's posts is that Elves, Numenorians, etc have to do something in order to radiate subtle magic. They don't. It just happens that way.
Which is because they don't look for these gifts. They might still sense them, but not understand what they are feeling. It's true, however, that Aragorn often chooses to hide his gifts (mark the words - chooses to hide, not chooses to display; they are there all the time).
Other characters who are not as high as Aragorn also have a similar effect on people. The first one tht comes to mind is Faramir. Imrahil brought cheer to warriors during the siege of Gondor, - well, he has Elvish blood in him, but he's not an Elf. Eowyn gave courage to Merry, but that strength was only revealed in action.
I tend to pay special attention to looks. When people look at each other's faces, there always seems to be something happening. There are too many instances to describe all of them, but here are some notable ones:
-Melian: with her gaze she does wonders. She communicates more with her eyes than with her mouth. Examples: gave confidence to Beren and "awoke" Hurin/told him the truth.
-Arwen looked at Frodo as he and Bilbo left the room, a moment that Frodo remembered for the rest of his life.
-Aragorn: when he looked up, the Breelanders would stop taunting him and the hobbits. There are other instances throughout LOTR.
-Gandalf vs Denethor "duel"
-Faramir: I don't know where to begin. Multiple times with Frodo, Sam, and Gollum (note: Pippin and Sam feel 'something' about him). Heals Eowyn from her darkness and, well, opens her eyes.
-Eowyn:
(Eowyn is already dressed as Dernhelm)
And also what I already mentioned - how she gave Merry the courage to stab the WIKI without knowing it.
Even hobbits have this. There's "something Elvish" about Frodo.
All in all, I think that glances are one way to express magic.
|
To me, this is all characterization. Tolkien created some strong characters that can convey personality and feelings to others. There is no need to assume any sort of occult force is in play. Words, facial expression and posture is sufficient. Scenes and characterization such as this can and do take place in stories outside of the fantasy genera in settings where there is no pretense of magic.
|
|
|