DAY 1
Jokes with
Lottie, saying she clearly confessed.
Quotes
phantom who discussed
Lommy & cobblers and says cobbler talk tends to be popular among wolves, but cobblers are more likely to give themselves away in a village like this.
Criticises
Nessa for voting someone who would be a "useful ghost" and doesn't like the reasoning
at all.
Says
Lottie had a good point about
Mänwe but seemed to be assuming both
Shasta and
Nog were innocent which is worrying.
Criticises
Boro for not explaining his vote (for
Legate).
Breaks the tie between
Mänwe and
Nog by voting for
Mänwe (because he looked worse, as she explains on day 2).
DAY 2
Criticises
Glirdan who called the
Mänwe lynch an easy bandwagon when his role wasn't known yet.
Speculates on whether the wolves thought
Shasta was Lúthien.
Agrees with
Lommy Boro looks like a cobbler dropping a hint (to a wolfish
Lommy). Doesn't vote.
DAY 3
Can't think of a way to use the double vote as a code, especially as there's at least one cobbler here.
Disagrees with
Legate on the post-reveal
Nog voters (
Fea,
wilwa,
phantom,
Lottie,
Ang,
Mith) looking bad - a seer impersonator is more dangerous in the living than the dead thread.
Says
Nog probably wasn't the seer, and
Nessa's apologetic vote for him looks worst.
Wilwa and
Lottie don't look bad just for defending
Nog.
Votes for
Nessa.
DAY 4
Surprised
Nessa got so many votes, but it's hard to make a case for wolvishness right now.
Questions
Lottie's &
ed's cobbler hunting.
Thinks
Mith looks the most innocent, and is getting worried about
Boro.
Says (in response to
Angu) that
Lottie is right about
Glirdan making an obvious wolf but her argument isn't better than "he isn't crying wolf", and while sally is often like this, she's posted so little she can't be called her usual self either. This is a pretty wishy-washy statement.
Doubts
Lottie would openly defend
Glirdan and
sally if they were her packmates.
Asks why
Lottie is so sure about
Angu being a cobbler without giving any real reasons.
Comments on
Green's sally analysis, saying she doesn't trust
sally but is getting a funny vibe from
Green as well (even though most of her points are valid).
Asks who we're supposed to check tonight and votes for
ed with
Quote:
Anyway, I have to go now, so–
++Elra
for looking an awful lot like a wolf-cub.
|
I can't say I'm overly fond of
Nerwen at the moment, she seems sneakily opportunistic. She said hardly anything about
ed before voting for her... And the way she speaks of
sally and carefully defends her while washing her hands looks bad.
If I had to guess now, I'd say the wolves are
Nerwen,
ed and
sally/
Green while the cobblers are three out of
Nog,
phantom,
Lottie and
Lommy.
Will vote soon.