Quote:
|
Originally Posted by phantom
Well then- what do you think? I would say that if the Dead find Lommy to be guilty then they should just keep checking our lynches, but if she turns out innocent they should check Nessa, for it would perhaps make that lynch particularly telling.
|
I think this is a good idea.
And I haven't poked at you,
phanty, because I honestly don't think you're that much of a threat. My gut tells me you're fishy, but you've been mostly helpful (if very vocal; but I'm sensing that's typical), though half of the helpfulness seems to be agreeing with
Boro (who is on my "Sensible" list, by the by). Also, the fishy-gut-feelings don't point to wolfishness, just general muck-up-the-works-but-still-be-helpful-enough-to-be-ignored cobblery.
Now, to do what I was going to before the 'Downs apparently went down (pun intended, sorry).
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Anguirel
I feel really bad about elron's last post actually. There's a sort of mad collective conformity in this village, er, camp, which she endorses, straight down the line, numerous times -
- "not sure" on people she's been prominent in helping kill
- in favour of the technocratic elite with their elaborate plan that involves evil counting
- the phantom could be a wolf ,but for some reason we shouldn't possibly interrogate him yet
- the lovers are innocent (well, yeahhh...)
- Loslote is a scatty innocent
It's just...unconfrontational and platitudinous. There are wolves in this camp. Elron, who do you suspect? At the moment the closest thing you have to a suspect appears, in my view risibly, to be Mith...
|
Grumble-grumble-I-really-should-start-phrasing-things-more-decisively-grumble. <kicks self>
I can't see how I've been "prominent in helping kill" anyone except
Lommy. Who I
did think was off. From Day one, if you recall. If you're referring to my calling
Lommy an enigma, that's because there are always things about her that I can't pin down.
I never said
phantom could be a wolf. I said he seemed fishy. Which I still think he does. But (as explained above), it's not wolfishly fishy.
Mith is currently on my radar, mostly because I can't get a read on her yet. Which is puzzling.
Yes, there are wolves. For all we know, they could be the quiet, busy-in-real-life ones.
Okay, that's all for my self-defense. (That sort of thing never ends well.)
I think
Boro's recent method (in conjunction with the original plan...
Agan's, wasn't it? I got a bit lost that Day) is a good one. I'm really not sure why anyone is reluctant on this. Don't we want to know about the Dead before we die ourselves?
EDIT: Right, duh, of course it was
Agan's plan. My brain apparently took an unexpected leave.