Quote:
Originally Posted by Shastanis Althreduin
Right, anytime Nogrod posts I'm just basically going to assume it's no more than "blah blah blah Shasta's stupid" and ignore it altogether - it's the only way my temper is going to survive this game.  |
Now please
Shasta. I did say I understood why you changed your mind, but it doesn't alter the fact that it was your decision not to check me. So if someone asks why didn't we check me, then it's you who has to provide the answer because it was your decision.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Aganzir
And I'm having serious doubts about the phantom. All his plans thus far seem to have been faulty - I don't care if he's plotting on his own, he seems to be misleading the village very slyly.
|
Which was exactly the reason why I dreamt of him on N2 (and which I explained there on D2) and found out he's a cobbler.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Agan
Will have to see what we can do about Nessa.
|
If
Lommy is voted, I'll check her. Whether you don't trust me as yet doesn't actually matter here. You say who you want to check by the voting (wolf or non-wolf?) and I'll pick the other one to dream (the exact role). You gain nothing with trying to trick me into dreaming the same person we vote for, but we would lose a lot (I'm still a firm believer you will change your mind in time when the other reasonable possibilities start to vanish and my points make more and more sense - and my dreams will show to be true every time).
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Lommy
I have read the dead thread and ugh I can't believe I'm really saying this... but I think Nogrod might have been the seer after all, which totally sucks. There's some stuff he says that I find unlikely he'd say if he was a cobbler (like "if I was a cobbler, would I intentionally be this mean?" or something along those lines), so despite his blunderings I'm starting to doubt...
|
I do recommend you others to try that same train of thought. Iwouldn't have been that angry and frustrated were I not the seer who got lynched way too early to help the village well - and have been feeling myself such a moron afterwards as it was partly my own mistakes that led into this.
And remember I said
Agan is Beren (not guessed, as I would have "naturally" guessed Lúthien then).
You seem to be getting the picture of
tp being the cobbler... well because he is - and I told it to you in no uncertain terms on D2.
Just consider.