[Glirdan]

Originally Posted by Boro

Nerwen has asked Glirdan a fair question about what he meant by the Manwe-bandwagon. I'm interested in Glirdan's response, but also, earlier I was not vehemently going after Nog. The above is what it looks like when I go into attack mode. Do you see the difference now Glirdy?

And apparently someone is not reading the thread entirely. I did answer her, post #207. And please note that even though I used the word attack, I did say that it was an overstatement, and I quote (myself ironically lol) with the part in question bolded:

Boro - All day, his attack (okay, maybe that's a little too strong of a word...his, thoughts and ideas will suffice for this) on [/b]Nog[/b] just made no sense to me. Granted, Nog has me a little baffled, but that's not unusual. But Boro's has been pretty adamant about it....I don't know, something just feels off.

Originally Posted by phantom

That's easy. I wanted to kill Lommy, but at that point it was impossible, so I had to vote for someone else. I wanted to rule out a multi-lynch, so I just boosted the lead of Manwe who was already guaranteed to die. Why put Legate or Nog under threat with my vote when I suspected neither of them? The death of one person you haven't particularly suspected is much better than the double-lynching of two people you don't suspect.

I see your reasoning....but why not vote for Lommy anyways? Manwe's fate was already stamped, sealed and set for deployment to Mandos. Why not stick with your gut and vote Lommy whether or not she standed a chance of being lynched? Your vote would have only mattered if it would have been placed on someone for a double lynch, but by voting last and by voting Manwe, you made a very safe vote. I don't know but it seems fishy. I don't think it Wolfish because that would be too obvious, but I would not put it past a Cobbler phanty.

Originally Posted by Nog

I do agree with Legate that Mänwe was probably an innocent. Basically because there was no last minute rescue-operation going on. In this kind of a game the wolves would save their mate on D1 with no problems.

I'm not sure what I think of this, but somehting about it is not sitting right with me. Just because there appeared to be no last minute rescue-operation doesn't necessarily clear him of having been a Wolf. And looking back, there was the possibility of a wolf rescue mission, of none other then yourself. There were two votes, made by Ang and Nerwen, for Manwe that were made within ten minutes of each other. I doubt both of them are but I feel quite certain that at least one of them could be a Wolf with you. Very tempted to vote for you.

Originally Posted by Lommy

A badly grounded vote is not the same as a throwaway. And obviosuly it was not throwaway, in retrospect, it determined the whole voting outcome of the Day. Now we just hope Mänwë was a wolf but I wouldn't bet too much on that.

Fair enough.