Cailin
#10 - IC banter.
#18 - likes
Boro. Approves of
Pitch. Wary of
Eomer. Votes
Agan, 'because I owe her one'. Typical random reason for a Day 1 vote, looks like.
#178 - Thought
Sally looked fairly innocent. This comment pings my radar a tiny bit, but it's a
Lottie-reason. Thinks
Lottie looks shady, looking at the
Sallywagon.
Feels good about
Legate,
Lommy,
Rikae,
Inzil,
Boro,
Eomer,
Kitanna, and
Agan. Says the wolves are
Mac,
Greenie,
Lottie, and
Nessa.
#186 - The start of an exchange with
Rikae regarding wolfish behavior and easy lynches.
Cailin thinks wolves are less likely to actively push bad lynches, feeling instead that it's more sensible to 'go with the flow and come up with a mildly credible explanation afterward'.
Also mentions
Nessa looks fairly bad after
Ozban's death.
#205 - Continuance.
Rikae wonders why a wolf wouldn't be actively seeking reasons to suspect someone, but would make unfounded accusations that were easily attackable.
Cailin responds with -
Quote:
Originally Posted by Cailin
I just think that completely unfounded accusations on Day 1 are actually easier and more convincingly defended.
|
I'm torn here. Part of me is thinking that this exchange looks innocent for both
Rikae and
Cailin, but then part of me is thinking
Cailin looks like someone who has just realized she's pulling more attention that she would like, and so ends her conversation.
Feels better about
Mac for much the same reasons I did, and would rather not lynch
Kitanna-hunter.
#220 - Continuance.
Rikae persists and
Cailin does more peacemaking "can we drop the subject" here.
#221 - Analyzes
Wilwa and
Nessa. As a conclusion, thinks
Wilwa is innocent ("I doubt she is evil") and
Nessa she says "has done little to make herself look innocent". I think I've said this before, but I don't really like the way this is worded, as if
Nessa being a wolf is a foregone conclusion.
#260 - Uncomfortable with
Lottie's vote and doesn't like
Wilwa's abstention - a bit of a flip flop from her previous post, where she says she doubts
Wilwa is evil.
#273 - Doesn't like what she sees of
Lottie, gives several reasons. Would not be averse to lynching
Nessa, either. Suspecting
Cailin for being against
Lottie is hypocritical of me, but I will say I'm not sure I like how she leaves herself open to vote
Nessa if the bandwagon swings that way.
#287 - A list of players: Guilty and Innocent. Of interest are the fact that
Wilwa and
Boro are "guilty", as opposed to how
Cailin felt about them earlier, and
Valier appears on the "guilty" side for a reason I'm not sure I understand.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Cailin
Valier - I remember Valier quite well from the distant past. She does not give me a fuzzy feeling as of yet.
|
I generally take 'fuzzy' to mean 'wolfish', which would make it odd that
Valier is there for
not being 'fuzzy'. Am I just misreading?
#296 - Votes
Lottie.
#346 - Says she had
Lommy down as innocent from the start. Will be looking at
Skip because she thinks
Valier was a suspected Seer.
#375 - Quick and dirty analysis of
Valier - says if the wolves thought she was the Seer,
Nessa and
Rikae look good and
Skip looks bad.
#378 - Mentions she went over
Lommy as well.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Cailin
Lommy was almost certainly not a we-are-looking-for-the-Seer kill but a let's-get-her-now-before-she-starts-making-sense kill or something involving Inzil (bluff, double bluff, you all know the drill).
|
I don't necessarily disagree, but I'm not sure I'd use the words 'almost certainly' in a werewolf game.
#381 - Thanks
Inzil for his
Elronhubbard analysis (I think?). Agrees, but pushes her suspicion of
Skip here, saying that his vote for
Elronhubbard looked like an attempt at a bandwagon.
#398 - Another list.
Wilwa is under 'others' as
Cailin doesn't like any of her posts (which comes as a surprise, considering her early analysis of
Wilwa, but
Cailin has been consistent regarding
Wilwa for a few days now, so I'm unsure). The rest of the list seems to be okay, but I confess I'm still waiting for the
skip analysis we were promised.
#402 - Puzzled by
skip's list, and puzzled by
Nessa's attitude. This post kind of feels like 'posting-for-the-sake-of-posting'.
#421 - Agrees that
Inzil and
Nessa will continue to be a distraction. Doesn't see any reason to vote
Boro. Still suspicious of
skip - what I'm not liking is that
Cailin continues to be 'suspicious' of
skip but makes no real effort to push said suspicion.
#427 - Votes
Inzil. Honestly, the reason about
Inzil's vote for
Boro at the last second is one I agree with - it
did look shady.
#431 -
Quote:
Originally Posted by Cailin
Coin tosses are bad but a throwaway vote for a silent player is not much better really.
|
Haha. I agree.
Conclusions -
Cailin is definitely someone to watch. She's got both good and bad points for her - I don't necessarily see full-blown lupinity here, but she's definitely more suspicious than I thought she was. (Wow, don't I sound wishy washy?
)