Quote:
Originally Posted by Inziladun
Eomer I might agree on, but why does Eomer being the BW depend on Agan's alignment?
I don't think Shasta's a likely wolf at this point, but I'm wondering if he might not be Ferny.
|
Only if he's really cleaned up his act since last time.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Inziladun
Quote:
Originally Posted by Loslote
Although, you'd think TB might have tried to hunt Eomer last Night...in which case, Eomer might be a wolf.
|
It's a pretty big "if", trying to guess who Tom was looking for, really. Eomer looks shady enough on his own. |
I have to agree: if
TB followed the arguments put forward yesterDay, it's probably about 50-50 whether he picked
Nog or
Eomer.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Loslote
Because the wolves might have thought he looked like the Seer. They killed someone last Night who looked like the Seer - Nog. Two people were talked about as possible TBW candidates yesterDay - Nog and Eomer - because the wolves might have thought they looked like Seers. Since they went after Nog, who was, of the two, less likely to look like a Seer, that suggests that they knew Eomer wasn't the Seer. They could only know that if he was a) TBW or b) a wolf. If Eomer is TBW, it suggests that Agan is evil, because in order to look like the Seer, his vote for Agan would have had to be right. If Eomer is a wolf, it says little about Agan's role, but suggests that she is not particularly likely to be Eomer's packmate.
|
In fact, we're now in the same position we were only
hypothetically in yesterDay, as regards the wolves picking Nogrod. So I guess all the "what-if" arguments now actually apply. Funny.