Well,
Greenie, your points against me are terribly subjective and vague on the whole. It's sounds like you'd already made up your mind about the outcome of your analysis before even getting started. I mean, these are just a few examples of your "arguments":
Quote:
Originally Posted by A Little Green
A
56: Long IC and the following: I'm always unnerved when people say that, but since innocents do it as much as wolves one can't really hold it against him..
...
Hmm. I don't like the manner of this. Of course it's almost impossible to have more than vague uneasinesses...
...don't like the phrasing.
...the first paragraph strikes me as false - but then again could be only IC so I wouldn't read too much into it.
...Not convinced by this reasoning, but that's about differing opinions and not about innocent/guilty.
...the tone of the first paragraph doesn't look genuine. That could be just my imagination though so I'm not giving too much weight to that.
...Again, understandable if he's innocent, clever if he's a wolf: backing off a little but being "still worried"
|
This seems worth replying to though:
Quote:
|
192 (in full): I - don't - like this. He was among the very first to point out the obvious scenario that Pitch was Shasta's dream - he left it for us to discuss at the very beginning of the Day - and yet he doesn't vote Pitch when the voting time comes but instead makes an odd vote for Legate. If he truly considered it was a real possibility Pitch was Shasta's dream, where did this vote come from? There is a reason, sure enough, but it doesn't look as convincing as "potential Seer-dreamed wolf". And we can't assume Skip disagreed with the "Pitch was dreamed of" -theory since he was among the first to bring that up.
|
I, much like all others it seems (bar the Wolves) though that Shasta could've dreamed
Pitch, that this was a likely scenario. There are however three wolves out there still and as I also found
Legate suspicious I felt another alternative could be wise to bring forwards, especially since the catastrophe of the Day 1 bandwagon. And the vote wasn't a throwaway, there was still enough people left to vote to change the outcome... In retrospect it would've been nice to have seen a closer voting too, wouldn't you say?
Edit: xed with Legate and Greenie whose question I've already answered.