Greenie, great job summarizing what everyone knows already. We know nothing, whatever the reason their (meant
Lottie and
Shasta of course) exchange had, we can't know. Unless they care to explain. I keep wondering what led you to writing such a list...
And yes, traitor/cobbler can be anybody, possibly one of those Cobb-hunt theoretists. Again, we know not.
For my part: that
Lottie-shasta conversation was most likely just a random recon. Wouldn't make too much fuzz around it.
Pitch:
Quote:
|
As for the matter of fake reveals which you broach there, I have yet to witness such an attempt being made successfully, but historical chronicles do mention precedences.
|
I hope you are not gonna change the history records. Would be troublesome you know, not that suprising though.
Legate: I'm so glad we (more like
Nerwen)
convinced you about importance of cobbler, I'm so glad you won't be "ignoring" him.
Quote:
|
Even considering what Nerwen said, I believe the Cobbler is not a threat. It can be so on some late Day, when there are few people left and he/she can vote with the Wolves to get rid of the villagers... Although okay, we are quite a small village here... hmm, I would have to count. Okay, I submit, maybe you are right and particularly in this village we should not ignore them for too long, but still, in the first Days it should not be our concern. And anyway, even in the later ones - I mean, we should look for WWs, not for Cobbler - once there are no WWs, the Cobbler has lost as well.
|
You know it would be a shame, ignoring threat of cobbler
completely. On the other hand, from what i got, Cobbler tends to fall into pit by himself, we are just the pendulum.
I wouldn't really assign any high priority to finding him. Just get rid of him eventually when he is revealed.
Aye, the false-reveal scenarios are dangerous, but is such a theory really worth such a witch-hunt? We are starting from the scratch. Without information of any sort we will probably witness several innocent die before we find a real cobbler.
Let's find WWs. That should be our priority. One point I'll agree on with Legate.
Later...