Given
Mira's relatively submarine performance, I find it incredible she was the Seer. It's even more confounding that the Elves figured that out.
I had a good feeling about
Foley already, and based on her late words that we shouldn't lynch
Nerwen for nebulous reasons, I was thinking
Foley could be the Seer.
I know
Shasta sort of did this already, but I'm doing it as well.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Mirandir
So... I read like a page and a half. Now have to go to a meeting, class, and work. Am grumpy about this fact. Would like to know what's in it for me if vote phantom for rep. Read more at work and hopefully make legitimate contribution.
|
The post that raised some eyebrows, especially in light of
Lottie and
Sally's votes for
tp.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Mirandir
Deal. And I'm holding you to that.
[highlight++phantom for rep[/highlight
|
Votes
tp for rep. Luckily, it was passed off as a joke or a lack of time by pretty much everyone.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Mirandir
Why actually I wasn't. Which I made perfectly clear in my first post of the day.
|
Admits she didn't read at all before voting.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Mirandir
*is a super epic fail at this game and would request modfire if Fea wouldn't literally eat her soul and probably forbid her to ever loiter at her house again ever*
On that note, I am in desperate need of a nap and will be legitimately around after that (given I don't die in my sleep or something). If there's anything in particular people would like me to respond to, condensed versions would be much appreciated.
|
No comment.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Mirandir
Immediate thoughts since they were requested; more detailed to come.
phantom doesn't feel evil - er, good? - to me. His attention getting ploys are slightly more ridiculous than when he actually has something to lose. Case and point - Seer reveal that in my opinion accomplished nothing.
Nog isn't making my head hurt, which a new and interesting experience. That does make me a tad suspicious with no backup for that though.
Mira is a pretty ridiculous fail at this game. This is what happens when people are forced to spend their entire weekend doing homework.
|
Fairly clear hint she could have dreamed of
tp. All right, he's probably an Orc. That still doesn't mean he's right about everything.
The words about
Nog aren't as clear. Seems ambiguous enough to have been just her opinion. That was Day 2, though. Why didn't she comment on her Night 2 dream if it wasn't
Nog?
Quote:
Originally Posted by Mirandir
Aaaand fail Mira for not actually saying what that massive post boils down to.
Pretty much I don't find sally all that suspicious. She's getting upset when people try to suspect her and I'm still not quite sure where her suspicion of Wilwa is coming from (although in all fairness, I very well might have missed it in the rush to get this done before DL), but nothing about that screams SoE to me.
Now I really want to know Wilwa, Shasta, and phantom's roles are just to see if I'm going to get proven wrong.
|
After an analysis of
Sally, in which she concluded
Sally was innocent. That
could have been a covert way of saying she'd dreamed
Sally. It seems logical that she would have, after Day 1.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Mirandir
x...The people I was going to make a case against need to stop being killed. They definitely need to stop being ordos too, because that's just leading me to question everything I've been thinking all game. Looks like Ima go reevaluate. Elfpoodoo.
|
This was after
Nog was killed. It would indicate she didn't dream of him, obviously. I wonder if the Night 2 dream might
not have been
Sally, in fact.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Mirandir
People I think are innocent:
Phantom
Nerwen
Shasta
Mira
People I suspect so are thus probably innocent:
Foley
People I tend to trust so are thus probably furry:
Kath
Rune
Steve
People I don't particularly have feelings on:
Greenie
Legate
Lommy
Zil
I'll elaborate more on that later, but the meeting I woke up for was cancelled so I'll be going back to bed now and hopefully not waking up again until my afternoon meeting.
|
There she has
tp,
Nerwen, and
Shasta as her "Innocents." No sort of analysis on any of them. It's conceivable those were her dreams, and finding
Sally innocent Day 2 was the result of her own reading. There's room for doubt, though, on the latter two.
Anndd....that appears to be it.
Based on that, I think we can at least conclude
phantom's innocence.
*mutters*
x/d with
Nerwen