Quote:
Originally Posted by Inziladun
I really don't like the way phantom seems to want to hide behind his own (admittedly strong) personality as an excuse for his actions. I don't know that he's evil, but his reactions to being suspected make me even more wary of him.
|
He's annoying, but there's currently too much evidence pointing away from him. Wouldn't be a good vote option.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Zil
Shasta is rather enigmatic. He makes me nervous for some reason, but I did like the fact that he challenged phantom.
|
Shasta did a lot to get
Lottie killed on Day One. I don't think he's an Elf.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Folwren
If Sally were smart enough as a seer NOT to do what she did, why would she not be smart enough as an elf not to do what she did? If Greenie thought she was smart enough not do that as a seer, why would Greenie think she was an elf when that move was almost equally as stupid?
|
Well, the dynamics aren't the same, though. If there's four wolves they can afford to be "silly"– the Seer can't.
However–
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Foley
Okay...so after looking at all of Greenie's posts, my main problem really lies with that she doesn't seem to have good reasons to suspect people. I think she weaves thick webs for the people she chooses to kill. Her web caught me and I killed Sally. I strongly think that Nerwen is innocent, and I think that Greenie's post against her is flimsy, but if I weren't so convinced of Nerwen's innocence, I can see being swayed by it.
|
See my last post on her.
EDIT:X'd with Zil.