Quote:
Originally Posted by Nogrod
Got a place beside a power-outlet...
Okay. It's D2 and after Lottielf's death we have a good reason to believe Sally is not an elf. I do agree with Nerwen that it is possible she is - like it is possible anyone of us is - but this is not the reason to lynch her because the odds are against her being an elf. And unlike with many others with whom we only have these ideas like "he could be a submarine-elf" or "she might have acted like that as an elf", with Sally we have the fact that an elf went in concord with her that openly in the beginning of the Day. That two elves did that is more improbable than any of our "could be's" or "might have's".
Although I must admit that everytime Sally opens her mouth I feel like suspecting her against the "facts".
Also, I think the phantom is innocent - and is no seer. If he wasn't dreamt of yet by the seer then now he is. So let's leave him be. Also, if I'm right in what he is doing he makes perfect sense in his own way we all should be used to.  |
1. As has been stated,
Lottie's vote doesn't really tell us much about
Sally and there's no reason to think they weren't elves together. Plus
Sally's first post of the day stinks of elvish soap.
2. Unless you're the Seer (which I doubt), you (obviously) can't know what the Seer's dream was last night. In fact, given that
Phantom didn't go through his "lol guys I was just kidding" song-and-dance yesterday before Night fell, I'd argue that the Seer probably
didn't dream
Phantom - what Seer dreams of someone who is, to them, already confirmed to be lying? The way you are in favor of just giving
Phantom a pass today strikes me as suspicious, and makes me think worse of you.