Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Wilwa
Well the way Lottielf voted for Phantom so early in the Day it almost seems like something she would have talked to the other SoE about during the Night, so for another SoE to also do it just seems strange. Also if Sally is an elf and voted like that, I don't know why her fellow elf would come on and vote the same right after, they must have known that would draw way too much attention to themselves, and I don't see them doing that. Like I said though, it doesn't make me feel fantastic about Sally, but I would still be a little surprised if she turned out to be an Elf.
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by Rune Son of Bjarne
About Sally, I am not quite sure what to make of her. I do think there is merit to Wilwa's thoughts, it would be very bold of two Elves to act in the manner Lottie and Sally did. So it does seem unlikely that Sally is an elf, but it is of course not impossible that SoE is extremely gutsy.
|
Think again.
First vote was cast by
Sally.
Second vote by
Lottie– who is indeed "gutsy" and also– perhaps even more importantly– inexperienced as a wolf. Look at how
Lottie played yesterDay– she
was quite unprepared for the amount of suspicion her vote attracted, You see, your argument is coming close to saying that
Lottielf wouldn't do something we know she did. That is, whether or not she voted right after her fellow, she did vote in a way that drew attention to herself, and in fact ended by getting lynched.
It could be that they had a plan to vote
phantom into power, either because he's one of them, or because they thought they could manipulate and perhaps frame him, but that
Lottie jumped the gun instead of leaving a decent interval before voting. It could be that there was no plan, but that Lottie decided to vote along with her mate anyway, because it was all a light-hearted early-Day-One party atmosphere and could be passed off as a joke.
It could be both
Sally and
phantom are completely innocent and
Lottie was up to some scheme of her own.
Whatever. The point is, it's highly premature to discount
Sally as a suspect based purely on what
Lottie did.
EDIT:X'd
with Sally herself.