Quote:
Originally Posted by the phantom
And honestly I think it may have paid off either way. If I'm the Seer then obviously it worked.
|
I don't know what you're up to,
phantom, but I repeat, I find it highly unlikely you're the Seer. I cannot believe a real Seer– even you– would make a completely pointless reveal on Day One. And don't say,
"Ah, but it's what they least expected! See how cunning I am!"
I don't understand why Seer-you would have any need to try a desperate double-bluff to cover yourself at that point.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by phantom
If I'm not the Seer then I think I may have wasted some of the time they spent on deciding their kill,
|
If you're not the Seer, you've made a false reveal that might bring the real one out in the open– and again, for no good reason.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by phantom
as Izzy was not definitively on board the Lottie-train so much as she was just the one who cast the final vote for her. I mean, what are the odds that Izzy would have happened to dream of the exact SoE who just happened to be on the chopping block at the end? No, no, there were other targets to go after besides Izzy.
|
Seers have dreamed of wolves on Night One. It's not that unusual. Plus, even if they didn't think she was the Seer, she was a nice logical kill-choice, as she'd made herself very hard to lynch by her role in killing
Lottie. (Killing her, note, not just "failing to save her". There's a difference.) Like I said, she's the person I most expected to turn up dead in the morning.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Inziladun
Since you're here, Nerwen, why did you cast your votes for Sally and Boro?
|
Because I had to vote in a hurry, and I thought there was a good chance at least one of them was an Elf.
EDIT:X'd with
tp.