Quote:
Originally Posted by mark12_30
I was actually pursuing the Troll's talking purse, which never bothered me, but which apparently breaks the enchantment for certain others.
|
But surely you can see where we are coming from though? I mean, there's no reason why the talking purse would bother a casual reader of
the Hobbit and it does add some fun to the story. But many of us here are übernerds who have even ploughed through various volumes of HoME (and that ain't always easy) in order to better understand the metaphysics of this fictional world, and from this perspective the idea of cockney Trolls with talking purses fits poorly into the later, more elaborate world of Arda that Tolkien develoved.