Quote:
Originally Posted by Morthoron
Actually, Eomer, Tolkien borrowed that scene directly from the Finnish Kalevala. It is as it was intended, without embellishment. It's Tolkien's version of fan-fic.
|
You know, Morth, I
thought I had read it somewhere, but my memory is bad and my Tolkien knowledge goes only so deep. Fascinating!
If we talk Kalevala, I can 'believe' in many of the characters and the struggles they encountered; however I wouldn't believe the talking sword scene actually happened. Same with Tolkien's myths. It might be a bit odd to divide a fiction into parts you believe and parts you don't, but there you go.
