Day 1: skip doesn't really say anything definite about anyone (it's mostly just banter), but his reasons for voting
EW look so forced that it seems he dreamed of a wolf and tried to come up with a decent explanation to vote for him. Difficult, given that he had just made one post.
Day 2: He analyses day 1's voting. While he doesn't say anything conclusive about anyone, he semi-defends
Fea by writing of those who voted for her in suspicious-ish light. He marks, though, that even her vote for
EW or
EW's for her don't clear her. The other two people he felt better about were
Lottie and
Boro for their votes that sealed
EW's fate. It could be said it points to a
Fea dream, but then there's this:
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Boro
Like for instance, today I'm feeling far more trusting of Skip today than yesterday.
|
To me it looks like there's something to it. They couldn't afford to be blatantly friendly with each other because otherwise the wolves would've noticed it, but I think he could have dreamed of
Boro.
Day 3: He suggests there were no wolves among the
wilwa-voters, ie.
Nerwen and
Greenie are innocent. Now, he couldn't have dreamed of them both on night 3, and he didn't treat either of them like a known innocent earlier. He is semi-suspicious of
Eomer,
Lottie and
Pitch, isn't too worried about
Fea, thinks I am rather cobblerish, and is very concerned about
sally (whom she voted for). I think he could have dreamed of either
Nerwen (innocent),
Greenie or
Fea. However, it's really weird he makes such a case of no wolf having voted for
wilwa because he obviously couldn't have known it for sure...
Day 4: He tells
Nerwen he wouldn't lynch her, pretty much saying "she's innocent". It would be rather dumb of him to say that without having dreamed of her. He considers voting for
Pitch, saying it looked like he and I were trying to frame him, but he didn't think I was a wolf. His dreaming of me might explain why he was so reluctant to reply to my points against him.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by skip
I expect that Lottie would reveal if she's the Seer with a positive on Eomer. That would be the wise thing to do at this point.
|
So does this mean he hadn't dreamed of
Eomer?
He considered voting
Eomer, me or
Lottie (because
Pitch was unavailable). It's pretty certain he hadn't dreamed of
sally - he talks so little of her.
Based on this, I'd suggest the following:
Night 1 -
EW
Night 2 -
Boro (maybe
Fea)
Night 3 -
Greenie (maybe
Nerwen or
Fea)
Night 4 -
Nerwen (maybe
Eomer or me)
Night 5 - could be anybody
Of course it's also possible he dreamed of somebody the night they died and we have therefore no evidence... But at least
Nerwen's innocence shouldn't be a question.