Quote:
Originally Posted by Dakęsîntrah
If they would have filmed the confrontation as it happened in the book, then it would have been a nearly wasteful bit of scenes. As a film director, why would you have one or two scenes of a book rendition of WK vs. Gandalf, building up even more tension than what was actually filmed, and then ending it with the two going separate ways with no actual outcome? Well, that's essentially how it happened in the book, but it certainly wouldn't carry any merit to advancing plot in a movie!
|
You have the two commanders of the opposing armies set up against each other; but there's no need to have them fight each other one-on-one if it didn't happen in the book - and it didn't.
The plot doesn't lose anything if no blow is struck between them.
It's this type of thinking that had the director seriously considering wheeling out Sauron himself to fight Aragorn at the Black Gate.