Is it alive? - Yes
Is it a Man? - No
Is it an Elf? - No
Is it an olvar? - No (nor a plant by any other name
)
Is it a Dwarf? - No
Is it a Maia? - No
Female? - No
Is it a Vala? - No
Manwë? - See above
Is it an Orc? - No
Is it a giant eagle? - No
Is it Tom Bombadil? - No
Is it an evil creature/individual? - Not evil, but definitely a creature, and quite individual
Is it in The Hobbit? - No
Did he live in the First Age? - Actually, scrap what I said above and make that a clear NO. I was just being nasty and allowing for a crazy theory which isn't substantiated by anything in the book. Sorry for any confusion this may have caused.
Did he take part in LotR? - Yes!!!
Is he a bird? - No
Ent? - No
Gollum? - No
Is he a wose? - We've established above that he's not a Man, which would include the Woses (or Drú-edain); therefore obviously No.
Did it help the fellowship in any way? - Yes, I think you could say he was helpful to
some of them.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by BG
THere's only two yes answers.
|
Indeed. Makes me wonder when any of you folks last visited a farm, zoo or circus... (Yeah, that was a hint!)
EDIT: x-ed with
Estanesse (hi, pleased to meet you!), question & answer added above.