Thoughts about Lottie
I honestly intended to do a post-by-post analysis of our current Queen of the Post Count, but it would probably take me all evening, and I don't quite feel up to it at the moment. What worried me most about her (actually the only thing that worried me) is her involvement in the near-DL discussion about/with
BG - it could be seen as increasing the pressure on BG and feeding the wagon without actually voting her (as she'd already voted me), or it could be seen as an innocent honestly questioning
BG and trying to make up her mind. Taking in account my general impression of her and her performance toDay, I tend to think the latter. So I'm still more inclined to trust her (and I also happen to agree with her about her top suspects).
Thoughts about wintywinty
#145 Is playing at last.
#146 extensive quote of Fleet Regulations (thank you, I think we've all read that!).
#150 question about the Agents.
#155 tries to make sense of the Night-kill based on
Eomer's suspicions (the first to try that, bonus points for that). Suspects me,
Zil, and
Noia based on
Eomer's suspicion list and my own list at #49. Nothing wrong with that, except that an experienced wolf wouldn't have left that clear a trail (as
Rikae said above).
Conclusion: Nothing morphish in him so far.
Thoughts on Zil:
He's been very laid back in general, almost keeping aloof, mostly rather reactions to others than taking initiative, but those reactions being balanced and reasonable - which is all very typically
Zillish. Only points against him the possibly incriminating Night-kill and final vote for
BG, but I liked his response to me about that. I also think a
Zilmorph would tend to be a tad more aggressive, so I'm still leaning to trust him.
Thoughts on Rikae
#27 banter about fake reveals and secret roles, joking suspicions of
sally and
Eomer; not-so-joking suspicion of
wilwa, serious point about Hunter reveals (although I've disputed it). Warning against jumping on her, or anybody, for flimsy reasons, which was a fair point at the time.
#120 agreed with
Lottie on
wilwa, found
sally's Nilping 'fishy'; I concur.
#121 Post-Count Wars (try harder, my dear!
).
#123 Berates the
BG-voters while admitting it's easy for her as a non-voter to talk. I agree with her on both points, and include myself in the latter, of course.
#167 Further comments on the
BG-wagon and
wilwa's ostentative non-involvement in it (which had raised a number of eyebrows before). Took the words right out of my mouth.
Conclusion: nothing morphish so far. (Next thing I know she'll probably suspect me for agreeing with her too much. If so, be my guest
.)
Thoughts about Izzy:
#52 IC banter, fake reveals entertaining, and a good point:
Quote:
|
Thinking someone couldn't be a metamorph because 'a metamorph would never do something that suspicious, or that x' .. doesn't necessarily work. Because a metamorph is obviously capable of anything.. add to that the specific player..
|
Indeed.
#58 thinks
sally should at least have had some kind of suspicion on some people, if not most. So she should.
#59 Question about DL.
#72, #74, #82, #92, were all about
BG and digested in my #158.
#164 responds to my examination of the
BG voters in a way that was very very defensive indeed, maybe bordering on omgus (if I'm getting the semantics of that term correctly). I'm not satisfied.
Conclusion: little participation for most of Day 1, some fair but obvious points, a hasty vote, and no satisfying response toDay. (Has she even acknowledged that
BG was
not a morph? A single 'Gah, I screwed up there' would have convinced me much more than the defense she's offered.) Tending rather morphish, but not my biggest concern toDay (I'm more worried about
Noia, if anybody hasn't noticed).
And that's about everybody who's still alive, right?