My thoughts on the cases presented:
Nerwen vs
Brinn
- what
Nerwen posted actually made me more suspicious of
Brinn, even though
Nerwen herself reached the opposite conclusion
- however, looking at the vote tally makes it beggar belief that
Brinn's a wolf (she's really not so evil that she could heartlessly vote her fellows Day after Day) and her latest post seems very innocent, so I'm leaning on considering her innocent
Nerwen vs
Skip
- good points
- BUT I think
Nerwen is trying to grasp at straws a bit - like
Agan said,
Greenie's comment on
Skip should not be forgotten (even though we can't take it as proof for
Skip's innocence)*. Not sure if that makes
Nerwen guilty, desperate or careless.
Agan vs
Nerwen
- again good points, very precise and concrete ones
- however, I again get the feeling of grasping at straws.
Nerwen is very scary and I'd be tempted to vote her just to be safe, so I get the uncomfortable feeling
Aganwolf is trying to abuse people's instinctive distrust of
Nerwen. It's hard to explain, but the case is so good that it is suspicious. Not sure if that makes sense, but it doesn't have the innocent trademark of being unsure. But - since
Legate missed my flip-flopping
- I have to give credit
Agan with making a good case whether it was with evil intentions or not.
*speaking of which, what do
you Skip think? Do you think it probable
Greenie dreamt of you?
edit: xed with Brinn