[Nerwen]

So, I have already talked about the way I didn't like Skip on Day 3, specifically his sheer persistence in defending Glirdan– and that was before we knew Glirdan was a wolf.

Here he is on the other two Days a wolf got lynched:

Skip, Day 2

#235. Asks why Lottie is now a known innocent.


#257
Finds Agan suspicious for making such a big deal about dumping retractables.


#268

Originally Posted by Skip

The wolves know the identity of the cobbler, right?

#270

Originally Posted by Skip

But does the cobbler know the identity of the wolves? I'm having problem figuring out the role Fea would try to play.

Comments: Those two posts could equally be either honest questions, or a wolf playing the newbie card– no way of telling.


#274
Find Glirdan and Nienna suspect for their Day One votes having apparently worked out for himself that throwaways aren't a good thing:

Originally Posted by Skip

Ok so from the wolves' perspective it did not matter if Fea or Lottie was lynched? They wouldn't care either way, it's all good.

So any wolf yet to vote would probably keep a low profile when it looked like either one of those two would die, you know act wishy-washy, and then come up with some half-decent explanation to vote for any random person

.


#400. "I'm here" post.


#423.

Originally Posted by Skip

So what's the current vote tally? Sally's dying, isn't she?

(is having trouble making any sense of the proceedings)

To which Sally responded:
#425.

Originally Posted by Sally

So far, yes, but you can still prevent it.

#429. Casts third vote on Glirdan.

Originally Posted by Skip

Gotta go to bed. Haven't got the focus now to get a real grip of what's been happening, but I understand Sally's got her back against the wall. I've had no real suspicion against her but I can see how some would find her behaviour creepy. Would be interesting to find out her role - she might well be a wolf but she would not be my first choice to vote for. Glirdan I've had a slight suspicion on since day one and although I've no clear picture of exactly what he's been up to tonight, at least he's not reassured me. So, in order to open up another alternative:

++Glirdan

General comments: The first part of the day, apart from his well-reasoned post at #274, Skip mostly just talks about the rules, while with both potential lynchees being wolves, it's hard to deduce all that much from the fact that he voted Glirdan over Sally. However, if in fact Skip is a wolf he'd have had to choose one or the other (or make a throwaway, which he'd earlier denounced) and he might have decided Sally was more valuable to the team. At that point, there were still several people left to vote, Izzy (#426) had said she would probably vote Glirdan, and Sally herself had more-or-less directly asked Skip to save her. Of course this last might just as easily be Sallywolf's attempt to implicate an innocent Skip.



Skip, Day 4.

#584

Just checking in briefly without having read anything in detail but Morsul, this is a very incriminating statement. A slip of the tongue perhaps, but one that could cost you your head.

Comments: ??? Seems to rest on an over-literal interpretation.


#621

Originally Posted by Skip

.
Yes, killing Greenie was a surprising decision (and I'll miss having her around). But what possible reason could the wolves have to believe she was the seer? From what I've gathered she was always perfectly ambiguous and vague about everyone, and tried her best to stay out of trouble. I was starting to suspect her as a wolf for these reasons. Could the wolves have felt that this was a reason to suspect her being the Seer, with the knowledge that she wasn't a wolf?

And why not Lottie? Two reasons I can think of. Maybe they think the ranger will protect her every other night and that the risk of missing out on a kill is too great. Or that the people Lottie now suspects are innocent, and that she's likely to cause as much bloodshed among the villagers as she already has among the wolves. I'm not so sure who's on top of Lottie's suspect list any longer though.

Morsul's odd though, wouldn't you say? Can't give this too much time but I will look into some of his statements now. There seems to be a pattern to his seemingly erratic behaviour, one that tempts me to cry... what is the word again ... oh yes wolf.

Comments: At this point Nogwolf, and the likelihood that Greenie had been killed for her suspicion of him, had been much talked about... yet Skip seems weirdly oblivious to this. If it wasn't for his quoting somebody-or-other, I'd think he hadn't read the thread.


#628
Post about Morsul. Raises some good points against him, but also continues that same strange accusation from #584. Think Shasta and Morsul might be the remaining wolves.


#635. Casts second vote on Shasta.

Originally Posted by Skip

Nogrod is starting to worry me too but I've not really kept up to date with the reading and just why he's suspected. Because Greenie the Seer's vote for him, is it not? It would be remarkable if we (though I can't claim any credit) could lynch a wolf three consecutive nights. Don't know if Nogrod is one but things are beginning to bad for him methinks. How do you behead a big grin anyway? Let's ask the The Queen Of Hearts shall we?

But I will not be the one to try to fit the noose around his neck or lack of. The most honest option for me is Shasta, who I've sort of suspected since early on. I could go for Morsul too but don't see that happening now.

++Shasta

*is off to sleep*

Comments: And Nogrod had only two votes at this point...

General Comments: Looks like he might have been trying to save Nogrod that Day, doesn't it?


Conclusions: Might be furry. Might also just be a very individualist new player who prefers to form his own judgements. However, it's enough that I'd consider voting him, anyway.