View Single Post
Old 03-08-2010, 03:27 PM   #211
Kitanna
Child of the West
 
Kitanna's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2003
Location: Watching President Fillmore ride a unicorn
Posts: 2,132
Kitanna is battling Black Riders on Weathertop.Kitanna is battling Black Riders on Weathertop.
Nogrod:
Day 1: Post 1: Mentions Nerwen's "go wolves" statement, Durelin's lunch statement, and Lottie's "let's not assume Boro is bad" statement.
Post 2: Pay attention to cobbler remarks now and not just later.
Post 4: Comments on Boro's post, but doesn't read it as a hint.
Post 5: Uncomfortable with Nerwen, confused with Glirdan, Sally is overagreeable, says Durelin is too attention seeking to be a wolf, but is bold enough at the same time, Boro is low-key, Wilwa is probably innocent, nothing on Izzy, I'm possibly a wolf for being calm and collected, feels okay about Pitch and Lottie unless they're in cahoots.
Post 7: Suggests who to look at based on personality.
Quote:
If you look for the reasonable and careful, look for Kit, Boro and Pitch.

If you look for the bold, look for Nerwen or Dury
Says he's baffled by Sally.
Post 9: Says he could vote for me as the wise and careful or could vote for Nerwen because her "go wolves" remark could be an intelligent move for a wolf. Wants to hear more from Pitch and Lottie.
Post 10: Comments on something Pitch said in regards to his "roundabout" response to Nogrod's Lottie-Pitch pairing.
Post 11: Says he was going to vote Nerwen or myself, but thanks to Pitch is reconsidering.
Post 12: Comments that Pitch and Lottie jumped as his mild suspicions of them being a pair. Suggests Pitch could be trying to strike up a friendship with an ordo.
Post 14: Talks about Boro
Post 16: Votes Pitch
Day 2:Post 1: Says the last voters of Lottie could blend in better, hiding their evil sides if they in fact have one.
Quote:
The only competition for Lottie was Wilwa so this could fit those who voted to bring Lottie even and past her. Also if Wilwa is a wolf, the wolves might have felt uneasy with Boro's vote and thus be more inclined to kill him at Night.
However, at this point he doesn't think of Wilwa as that suspicious.
Post 2: Discusses just what had his eyebrows raised on Day 1 in regards to Nerwen. But also why he suspected Pitch.
Post 3: Discusses the votes for Lottie, starting with Durelin who had tied Lottie with Wilwa. States Durelin has never mentioned Wilwa or Nerwen. Points out Glirdan breaks this tie. If I haven't misread says Izzy went after Lottie with determination and Nerwen's vote sealed the deal.
Post 4: Doesn't like that Nerwen voted Lottie though she suspected her only of being the cobbler.
Post 5: Says I give him the creeps.
Post 6: Kitalysis
Post 7: Durelin and Sally could be innocent. Lists why the rest are suspicious.
Post 8: It's between myself and Izzy for him.
Post 9: Votes Izzy after making his case in previous posts.
Day 3:Post 2: Comments that Nerwen and Izzy pressed on Lottie, both voting for her and appear to be doing the same now.
Quote:
Now Sally may be a baddie. And Izzy & Nerwen can be both innocents. But what bothers me is their clear lack of interest to take a wider picture or trying to look outside the box they have chosen to stay in both of them.

Concentrating one's effort on someone who is a good lynch candidate and being careful not to offend or suspect anyone else is just soo wolfy...

Izzy and Nerwen have done that twice now.
Conclusion: Um, almost none. He's been committed and has given plenty to ponder, but I don't see anything wolfish in him or anything truly innocent. I am completely on the fence in regards to Nogrod.

Durelin:
Day 1: Post 2: Pairs her wolves as Nogrod-Lottie, Glirda-Me. Cobblers = everyone else and lynch Sally regardless.
Post 4: Explains grouping.
Quote:
Basically, Nogrod's first couple posts gave me a vibe of some vague sort. Loslote is annoyingly agree-able and like 'im going to be helpful!' But so is Sally.

Glirdan seemed like low-radar wolf somehow, and Kitanna seemed like 'I'm going to be the sense in this chaos and skate through silly Day 1 mwaha.'

But Pitchwife could be the same thing.

And Isabel is low-radar skater wolf.
Post 7: Votes Lottie, but has at least mild suspicions for Sally and Wilwa.
Day 2: Post 3: Says she's not caring for Glirdan or Wilwa, now is that not caring as in no opinion or not caring for them in a "they're evil" way? Says Izzy is bothersome in her quietness and I'm creepy. Seems to suspect Pitch and Nogrod the most.
Post 4: Comments on some of Nogrod's points. One being that I got a free pass for not being a later voter for Lottie and also Izzy's question about vote retraction was interesting.
Post 5: Responds to Sally going after me based on Durelin's "Kit is creepy to me" remark. Says Nogrod and Sally both took this remark as Durelin thought I was sinister.
Post 6: Explains why she thought Pitch was giving free passes. Doesn't know how to vote and doesn't know how she feels about Glirdan (who at this point had a few votes I believe).
Post 7: Sally or Nogrod? Votes Sally
Conclusion: As far as her Day 1 accusations in that first set of groupings go I like how she accuses several people of trying to fly under the radar when she has been doing that. She's been a slippery one so far, keeping low, commenting enough to get by and sticking pretty well to those she suspects. Yet if people (Sally and Nogrod) in particular quote from her she distances herself from them. That's pretty unsettling to me

My top suspects are as follows:
Sally: She's been very vague in her suspicions and abandons suspects for those who seem to be gaining a potential lynch following. Day 1 she votes Wilwa, she had a few "gut feelings" about her. Wilwa had one vote at this point and she was talked about enough that more could have followed. She also asks people to stop looking so much at Wilwa because there are two wolves in the village, but she votes Wilwa...
On Day 2 she votes for me, moving herself off the fence only after Durelin and Nogrod calls me creepy. At the time of her vote there was a 50-50 chance Nogrod would also vote for me.
Izzy: She's a vague one too. As Nogrod put it she doesn't try to get on anyone's bad side really. This sort of vague playing and going on gut feelings after Day 1 (as Sally has done) is a good way for a wolf to hide. However, if Sally is a wolf I'd say Izzy isn't (and vice versa) because it seems unlikely that both wolves would be so non-committal.
Durelin: She's been just active and reasonable enough to garner attention, but not to actually gain much momentum as a lynch choice. As I said above, yesterday she distanced herself from Nogrod and Sally when they began quoting her. I find that an interesting move.

I'll be back a few hours before deadline to vote.

x-posted with Sally and Nogrod
__________________
"Let us live so that when we come to die even the undertaker will be sorry." - Mark Twain
Kitanna is offline   Reply With Quote