Okay... just finished reading the thread.
First off, I'd like to say that I'm not sure why this suspicion of Kit (from
Nogrod,
Sally and
Dury), as she hasn't struck me playing evilly, and in fact seems to me one of the most reasonable and useful players.
Now, to comment on something
Kit herself said–
#153.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Kitanna
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Glirdan
This post makes me leary. I am still quite adamant that she is no ordinary villager...but this makes me lean towards her being a Cobbler and not a Wolf...Thanks for possibly shooting a hole in my Wolf on Wolf theory
|
Now the post of Nerwen's he comments on suggests two wolves will distant themselves so as not to leave a line to the other so early. It seems to me he abandons his thoughts of Nerwen as a wolf based on this. Why should she be the cobbler and not the wolf? Why couldn't it be Lottie who was the cobbler in his mind? |
Also– this is perhaps a little thing– but
why is he "adamant" that I'm "no ordinary villager"– when his suspicion of me was based entirely on the theory that Lottie and I were wolves staging a fight? It sounds to me like he's just echoing
Sally at #104, where she says
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Sally
I'm recognizing a change from 'normal' Nerwen behavior and whether she's cobbler or wolf I'm leaning toward an evil roled Nerwen more than a gifted Nerwen.
|
And in fact all his suspicions have that "going with the flow" look to them. Reminds me a lot of the way he played last game.
As for
Sally herself– in that same post, all
her suspicions are variants of "Just seems evil. Yeah." Which is, at best, very lazy playing.