Quote:
Originally Posted by Nogrod
First of all, how did this thought of us knowing Sally had dreamt a wolf come from? At least to me it was not obvious and I didn't find it even now looking back the thread.
Sally said in her first post as an answer to alona's question "any luck dreaming of a wolf?" the following (boldings mine): To me and my understanding of English-language that seems like far from clear she had a wolf. Actually it looks like the contrary - but she was clearly wishing to play games with the wolves (like saying she had two wolves the Day before etc.). So at least I took that as something I couldn't and shouldn't rely on.
|
Okay, so this might get me in trouble, but I'm going to say it anyway for clarity's sake especially now that
Sally's been killed. Since she and I were on for most of yesterDay, we ended up talking about the game while simultaneously posting on the thread. The main point of our conversation was covered and posted on the thread when
Sally basically asked if it was all right if I sacrificed myself as a lynch so the Ranger wouldn't get lynched. Now, at the time, I was okay with her setting me up as the Ranger as a hopeful hint to the wolves to go after me instead of trying to lynch or Night kill the real Ranger.
Because I'd been privy to this information, my posts yesterDay were written based on the knowledge that
Sally had in fact dreamed a wolf. I think everyone assumed
Sally had dreamed a wolf at that point - and she certainly gave that impression the way she was posting and how she was talking.
Nog, breaking a post down word by word might be helpful to catch a slip by a wolf, but in
Sally's case, I think it needs to be taken with a grain of salt. Some of what she said could have misdirects, and I think that's what the whole "might" business was.
And to use some logic you used in making a case against me earlier, it feels like your post could go one of two ways: an innocent vehemently defending himself in order to preserve the village numbers or a wolf throwing a fellow pack mate under the bus. I'm leaning towards the first, but am not disregarding the second just yet.
Your reasoning does seem sound, but knowing what I know after talking and posting with
Sally after all of most yesterDay, there's just something that doesn't sit completely right with me.
I've got to leave for work now, but I'll be back roughly an hour and a half before DL or so, depending on traffic on the way home.