Mac
Day 1-
#27
Mnemo does a wonderful job at a
Form impression and hating Day 1s
#57
Mnemo ignored the reasonable debate of uselessness
#112
Mnemo seems innocent
#139 wants to avoid voting
Mnemo
#161 prefers
Inzil over
Mnemo, and does vote
Inzil.
Day 2-
#190
Mnemo has vague reasons for voting
Inzil
#217 several good points have been made against
Mnemo
#248 suspects
Mnemo and asks
Nog if his # of suspects is enough for him
#257
Mac's analysis on
Mnemo, if
Nog's guilty
Mnemo would look suspicious.
#260 lists
Mnemo is suspicious
#313
Mnemo's defending of
Nog is suspicious
#386
Mnemo sounds like an ok choice
#390 votes
Mnemo (4/7) and puts her in the lead by 2
#411
Mnemo's role would reveal more than
Lottie's
Of
Mnemo voters,
Mac looks more like wolf-on-wolf than the others. The placement of his vote would be brilliant too. With
Mnemo being under suspicion from Day 1, I think a wolf pointing suspicion towards her on Day 2 is a likely scenario, that's not just some cracked conspiracy theory. Also, notice that while he does consistently point towards
Mnemo being suspicious he tries to nudge the suspicion more towards
Nogrod. It's not "If
Mnemo is guilty than there's a chance
Nog is," it's "If
Nog is guilty, this looks bad for
Mnemo." That could just be because
Nog honestly was his primary suspect, which I could understand seeing how
Nog's case about the number of people
Mac was suspecting was faulty.
I'm considerably less confident about
Mac today, but not going to vote on him for that type of weak speculation. And if he is a wolf, it is pristine and stunning wolf-play, which
Mac is fully capable of doing, but can he go the distance?
Nog
Day 1-
#158 doesn't find
Mnemo suspicious, but he has been unclear about her since the latter part of the day.
Day 2-
#207 doesn't like
Mnemo's vote and the whole coin-flip
#233 repeats reasons from #207
#356
Mnemo has made 2 odd votes now
#372 repeats reasons from #356
#405 agrees with
Mac that
Mnemo's wierdness looks more evil than
Lotties
#413 votes
Mnemo (6/7)
-Then in another post, agrees with
Mac that
Mnemo's death would reveal more
It's good to see
Nog repeating himself...
, but in a seriousness the vote the vote placement could be another wolf-on-wolf, but on my own feelings
Nog looks better than
Mac now. Yes he repeats his reasons against
Mnemo a few times (is that a good sign? Not sure) but I like the details he uses plus bringing some new stuff to the table on Mnemo like in posts 207 and 356.
We've clearly disagreed about
Lottie, but
Nog tends to be more of the conspiracy theorist, and I detect nothing sinister in his doubts on
Lottie's reveal.
By th way, I realized I had more of these to go than I thought...forgot about
Morsul,
Brinn, and
Pitch. I feel like I would just be repeating myself, on feeling generally good about them. I've got to go grab some food, I'll be back to read all that's taken place and then vote.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Pitchwife
Wow, a gifted reveal again. These Days, hardly a game would be complete without one or two, it seems. I must say I expected some more glamorous secret role, but that's a matter of taste, not an argument.
I think I can understand Lottie's reveal. YesterDay's bandwagon came rather late in the Day, she couldn't be sure it wouldn't happen again, and not knowing for sure whether she would be able to come back later toDay, she didn't want to take the risk of losing her chance to dream. Especially as it's her first time as a Gifted, she'd be anxious to do it right.
Anyway, I also think we can rule out the possibility that she's wolvish. Supposing yesterDay's Lottie-wagon was fueled by one or more wolves trying to save Mnemo, as seems likely, does anybody really think they would have put up another packmate as the alternative candidate?
So, let's give Lottie her chance, I think it'll do us good.
(I guess I'm hardly the first to say any of this, but nevermind. And for once, I'm letting it stand without any qualifiers and on-the-other-hands; it'll take some practice, but maybe I can make that a habit.)
|
Yes, you've said some things others have, but I'm going to tell you, that you're actually not being agreeable in this post. You might have some reservations about the reveal, and are repeating a few things, but you've added a new perspective that hasn't been mentioned. That is, supposedly
Lottie was an attempt to save
Mnemo.
Perhaps someone will speculate that it's possible
Lottie's a wolf too, who got into trouble, therefor this is her attempt to get out of a lynch. But you can imagine all the assumptions one has to make to dream this scenario, while ignoring all the other facts about what makes sense in
Lottie's reveal. Plus, if anyone tries to say they were saving
Mnemo because she was making more sense than
Lottie, than I will definitely beg to differ on that point!
Edit: crossed with whoever posted since
Pitch's post I respond too