I'm writing a reply as I read, so forgive me if I repeat stuff people have said...
I'm currently finding
Mac quite innocent, andf looking at his vote summary,
Shasta and
Nienna (ha!) seem slightly bad. YesterDay's voting was quite a mess, and to be honest, I have no idea what to make out of it, except that, like I said, I think
Mac is innocent, and possibly
Inzil too. That would make it slightly more probable that
Mnemo is guilty, or then we are really unlucky.
I'm kind of grudging
Legate for making this "humane decision" event. Because now we don't have any dead ie cleared people. And no wolf-kill tracks to follow (although this will be one of those painful games where the kills are more confusing due to the lack of a seer). So it's kind of good
Roa had to leave (although that was sad
) because that means we have some information.
Nogrod's case on
Roa is just absurdly over the top, it doesn't make any sense. I really wonder if that makes him a wolf. Because that would be the only reason I could see him doing that, "ooh I'll be so crazy and over-the-top that no one will believe I'm actually a wolf"...?
Mnemo is odd.
Can someone accuse me or get me otherwise very involved? Because I feel strangely "unattached" from this game, I'm reading it as if I wasn't playing it myself. Hmph.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Mnemo
I should add that Roa's departure puts paid to my theory that she and Nog were our gifteds staging an uprising. Phooey.
|
Glad I wasn't the only one thinking that.
Nogrod has quite good points against
Pitchie, but I still wonder about him too.
I'm not sure what to make of
Lottie's vote for me. It is poorly reasoned, but not necessarily evil. She's not so much of a newbie anymore, though, so I would expect more depth from her.
Well but really, she just summarises what I said, doesn't criticise it all or tell why it is suspicious and just votes me. *raises an eyebrow*
I'll be back and more involved later! I'll leave you with a list based on gut-feeling and all the points I've brought up this far:
Leaning innocent
Boro
Mac
Inzil
Greenie
Eomer
In the middle
Bes
trom
Morsul
Lottie
Sally
Brinn
Wilwa
Nerwen
Leaning guilty
Mnemo
Nogrod
Nienna
Pitchie
Shasta
PS. I really feel pitifully uninvolved. I promise I try to do something about that when I come back from school.