[Bes]

Mac:
#18 In Character
#27 Making a summary, forming early suspicions about Inzil
#57 Doesn't believe Boro is a wolf, forms new 'maybe' suspicions about Pitch and maybe Nerwen.
#93 Responding to Morsul, Nerwen and Inzil.
--------#59 Morsul makes a point that if I'd been payying attention I would have concurred with.
----------------Mac responds sensibly that the statements would be similar, since it was so early, little evidence to go on.
----------------Suggests here that he felt negatively about Inzil and positively about Pitch. Odd, that's not what I read. I'm hardly in a position to call someone on detail consistency, though.
--------Mac goes on to say that Morsul's vote seems to come directly from "Disagreements about Nerwen and Boro"
----------------Morsul's reasoning in #69 IS kind of weak, but not so weak as to be dismissable I feel.
------------------------Mac's response is that if Boro continues his argument, he'd get lynched, so a wolf wouldn't risk it. The complete lack of votes on Day 1 for Boro seems to negate this dismissal of Morsul's reasoning.
--------Mac responds to Nerwen, nothin here catches my attention immediately.
--------Mac makes a good point about Inzil, but nothing truly damning. Again, early.
--------Mac affirms that Roa can't be suspected on flimsy evidence. We all know how that turned out, whee.
#112 Another list! Ceases to suspect Inzil, Nog is strange, Nerwen is forceful but not suspicious, Morsul looks good(?), Pitch is suspicious again.
Boro, Roa and Mnemo are innocent. An appearance of consistency, other than Pitch really.
Summary of people who haven't posted enough, people who haven't posted, and people who have good reasons to have not posted much.
#116 Has been tuning out Nog-Roa-Boro. What? You just went back and forth about it with Morsul, and talked openly about it in your last three posts.
Deflects attention onto Nog and posts #80 and #91. I'm not sure what to think about that.
#139 Now only even tentatively feels like Inzil, Nog or Lommy might be worth voting for. So, again reversing on Pitch, Inzil this time as well. Not happy with his options, but none of his options are explained.
#155 List of votes up to that point.
Points out that on Day1 it's not unusual to jump back and forth about suspicions in response to Inzil.
#159 Bandwagon, onoes! Does two count as a bandwagon? I don't think it does. Even with the speculation that Inzil would likely vote for him... It feels off to claim that this post is anything other than what it appears to be on the surface. Moving on!
#161 Inzil plz. No one new has voted for him yet. Or had much time to do so.
#167 Thanks to Nienna, who concurs with Mac. Which means I'll have to analyze her too now. Head hurts...
#172 Brief reply to Inzil, defending earlier reasoning in a previous response.
#175 Just a vote count
#177 Hesitant vote for Inzil.
#184 Lynched (almost)
#190 List time again! And we're finally back to today. Vote count, in order of votes complete with tally.
--------Suspects Pitch again, and it looks like also Mnemo, Me (understandable), Shasta and Nienna (what? Really? Ok then.), and maybe Nerwen.
#197 fun with Boro, Nog, and a book.
#217 Suspicious of Pitch and Mnemo for certain. Making me suspicious of Pitch, goodness. There's more here, but I'm trying to hurry up a bit now, it's 12:16 as I type and none of it stands out greatly.
#248 Explains why Morsul's vote for him was reasonable. Reply to Inzil, comments on how Boro defends Mac better than Mac does, refering to #231 where Boro makes some good points about interpretation of information.
Mac also blasts Nog's claim that he's been careful not to suspect too many people. I'd say that's half accurate, since it's more like he never suspects too many people in one sitting. And, to be fair, they have mostly been variations on Pitch, Inzil, and person X when appropriate. At the moment that's been upped to Inzil, Mnemo, Pitch, Sally, Lommy, Nerwen and myself.
There's more here, but if I don't move on soon then I might as well just quote the whole post.
#257 List/Analysis of Mnemo.

If I'd looked this closely on Day 1, I probably would have been equally as likely to consider Pitch or Nog for a vote as Mac, and/or not voted. That said, they're all on my watch list now, but I can't say who I think I'm going to vote for today. I'm probably going to have to reread the entire thread tomorrow, if I can manage it.

Probably crossed with several people. ... On the one hand this is all fun, but I think it might be a relief when it's all over, too. And we just got started. X_x