[Nerwen]

Originally Posted by Roa_Aoife

So, quickly before I head out for the night (my time), it doesn't need stating but I'll say it anyways: The wolves could not have known that Greenie was the cobbler. Ergo, her lynching should be looked at as the lynching of an innocent.

No, just as that of a non-wolf. People may well have honestly found her suspicious; you can't treat voting her as guilty behaviour in itself. Cobblers aren't innocents and typically don't act innocently. And wolves usually try to avoid lynching whoever they suspect is the cobbler unless one of the pack is on the block. (Whether that was the case remains to be seen.)

Originally Posted by Roa_Aoife

Fea- also her second time lynching an innocent. Voted Greenie to save herself. I suppose it's understandable, but I didn't at all like the way she went along with Lari's theory. It was extremely convenient for her, of course, but the flaws in it were obvious, as Nerwen pointed out. I also think her post about lynching her not helping the village sounded very wolfish. After the events of the last Day, she looks the most suspicious to me.

As I said, I don't regard voting Greenie as inherently suspicious. The other points still hold, though. (I still don't understand why Lari kept arguing about Hakon. It's possible he hadn't dreamed any of his three Bear-candidates yet, I'll grant that– but that wasn't her theory.)

Originally Posted by Inziladun

Lari? I had her pegged as a likely wolf, owing to her Day 1 vote, and what I saw as an over-the-top response to the suspicions raised about her. And Greenie was the cobbler.

Indeed, why Lari? She'd practically stuck her head in the noose by the end of yesterDay. It would have been very easy to get her lynched toDay. Were they that afraid of the Ranger?

Here's an interesting point: consider that if Fea is innocent, she and Lari would have surely looked very like the Lovers to the wolves (unless it's in the rules that the Lovers are opposite sex; I couldn't see that anywhere). However, that would not be an incentive to the wolves to kill Lari, but rather the reverse. You see, in this game the Lover-rules are as follows:

Originally Posted by The Rules

If one Lover is killed, the remaining one gets a revenge kill, which must be used within three Days of their counterpart's death.

Originally Posted by The Rules

In some games the remaining Lover dies after getting their revenge kill, but we decided to let them keep playing for kicks.

So, the obvious explanation is that Lari didn't look like Fea's Lover to the wolves for the simple reason that Fea is one of them. But in that case, you'd think they'd keep Lari alive in the hope that she'd be lynched instead of Fea.