The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum - View Single Post - T-I-G LXVII: The Rangers of the North

Nienna · 09-24-2009, 08:31 AM

I agree with Greenie about captains.

Here is a quick analysis of Nerwen:

42. Answers one question from Boro’s quote, says we need to take the Captain thing seriously and is suspicious of those people who actively say they want to be captain

Wolf-Nerwen on Bold-Wolf-Rune? Doesn’t feel like it.

43. Doesn’t know what Fea and Boro are doing or why Fea shed her retractables

Popular opinions

96. Defends Fea’s use of her retractions on Boro, asks Legate why he picked me to ask about innocence and what he concluded.

Seems fine

128. Says the problem is that anyone who would make a good captain would also make a good were-captain. Votes Roa for captain as she has more leadership qualities than Rune, votes Kath for NG as it seems the wolves like to kill her off early

Both these seem reasonable

143. Says that Hakon is being weird

149. Says that Hakon has to be a wolf eventually but she thinks that if he was a wolf his pack mates would have advised him against doing what he did.

I’m not really sure what “he did” that is being discussed which worries me

160. Votes to lynch Boro because of the Fea thing, has no other real suspects except Hakon but doesn’t want to vote him because of what happened last game

She did have some suspicion of Boro so this seems fine though it almost feels like she is trying to get the village to suspect Hakon without voting for him herself.

263. Makes a very weird midNight post on the game thread.

Very weird.

298. Congratulates Hakon for a job well done, makes a good point about wolves trying to not change their playing style from normal, makes a point that the wolves may not have wanted to openly support Rune but having him as Captain would have been such an advantage that they probably pushed for it

Very good point about the wolves, though congratulating players for helping the village can feel superficial

301. Wonderful vote table, shows connections between the Rune for Captain voters. She makes Val and Lottie look bad but then reminds us that Zil would have looked guilty too

She seems like she is trying to give us as objective view as possible

304. Puts all of Mac’s posts together. Notices that killing him would make me and Sally look bad while making Kath, Brinn, Roa, and Legate look good, mentions she’s surprised the wolves didn’t leave him alive to frame him.

I agree.

310. Clarifies her previous post and agrees with Lommy that because killing Mac would make Sally and I look bad we look more innocent

In conclusion: Nerwen is looking more innocent to me than guilty. She makes some good points, says logical things about players, tries to be objective (or at least make it look like she is trying to be objective)… basically she is going on my leaning innocent list but I will continue to look at her.

09-24-2009, 08:31 AM	#319
Nienna Ghost Prince of Cardolan Join Date: Mar 2009 Location: School Posts: 642	I agree with Greenie about captains. Here is a quick analysis of Nerwen: 42. Answers one question from Boro’s quote, says we need to take the Captain thing seriously and is suspicious of those people who actively say they want to be captain Wolf-Nerwen on Bold-Wolf-Rune? Doesn’t feel like it. 43. Doesn’t know what Fea and Boro are doing or why Fea shed her retractables Popular opinions 96. Defends Fea’s use of her retractions on Boro, asks Legate why he picked me to ask about innocence and what he concluded. Seems fine 128. Says the problem is that anyone who would make a good captain would also make a good were-captain. Votes Roa for captain as she has more leadership qualities than Rune, votes Kath for NG as it seems the wolves like to kill her off early Both these seem reasonable 143. Says that Hakon is being weird 149. Says that Hakon has to be a wolf eventually but she thinks that if he was a wolf his pack mates would have advised him against doing what he did. I’m not really sure what “he did” that is being discussed which worries me 160. Votes to lynch Boro because of the Fea thing, has no other real suspects except Hakon but doesn’t want to vote him because of what happened last game She did have some suspicion of Boro so this seems fine though it almost feels like she is trying to get the village to suspect Hakon without voting for him herself. 263. Makes a very weird midNight post on the game thread. Very weird. 298. Congratulates Hakon for a job well done, makes a good point about wolves trying to not change their playing style from normal, makes a point that the wolves may not have wanted to openly support Rune but having him as Captain would have been such an advantage that they probably pushed for it Very good point about the wolves, though congratulating players for helping the village can feel superficial 301. Wonderful vote table, shows connections between the Rune for Captain voters. She makes Val and Lottie look bad but then reminds us that Zil would have looked guilty too She seems like she is trying to give us as objective view as possible 304. Puts all of Mac’s posts together. Notices that killing him would make me and Sally look bad while making Kath, Brinn, Roa, and Legate look good, mentions she’s surprised the wolves didn’t leave him alive to frame him. I agree. 310. Clarifies her previous post and agrees with Lommy that because killing Mac would make Sally and I look bad we look more innocent In conclusion: Nerwen is looking more innocent to me than guilty. She makes some good points, says logical things about players, tries to be objective (or at least make it look like she is trying to be objective)… basically she is going on my leaning innocent list but I will continue to look at her. __________________ Puddle! Puddle!