Quote:
Originally Posted by obloquy
The film resurrection of Gandalf implies only a resurrection; his return as The White, perhaps, an enhancement. Neither reveals Gandalf's true nature as a primeval demigod of Sauron's peerage, and therefore Gandalf remains only what the filmmakers want him to be. Since they define him for the films, his enhancement is not incongruous with his defeat by the WK. The scene simply implies a new power in the WK that Gandalf was not expecting, and also that Gandalf's enhancement was only to some tier of potency above his incarnation as The Grey and below the new-and-improved WK's.
|
obloquoy, you are downplaying a significant aspect of the movie, and in effect proving the inconsistency of Peter Jackson's scripting. PJ went out of his way to show Gandalf's efficacy against the towering balrog inferno, of his ethereal resurrection (with the caveat that he was brought back specifically to finish his mission), his crushing defeat of Saruman and the assumption of his role at Orthanc, even his driving away of the Nazgul while rescuing Faramir; in contrast, the movie Nazgul are never shown to be invested with such power. They are driven off by a brand-waving Aragorn on Weathertop, they are drowned by an Elvish maid (Arwen, wishy-washy throughout most of the movies, is seemingly invested with the power to drown them -- nowhere is Elrond credited with the deed), a flying Nazgul is easily driven off by a few arrows at Osgiliath, and then Gandalf magically drives them off in front of Minas Tirith. Nowhere does PJ intimate that the WiKi has such power, but suddenly Gandalf's power is trivialized in a single action by a suddenly omnipotent opponent. Then, just as incongruously (in the movie anyway), Eowyn destroys the invincible WiKi with a jab of a sword.
The incongruity is in the scripting. Somehow part-time shield maiden Eowyn is more powerful than the balrog-smoting Gandalf? That's what the addled inference is. Inconsistency -- picking and choosing jumbled aspects of the story in order to glorify special effects -- this is the infuriating aspect of the films.