I think "the right thing" is largely subjective. Many mortals that would regard immortality, and the opportunity to live in bliss (though Aragornless) in Valinor, as the ultimate prize, might think that Arwen did not do the right thing. That she threw away a great gift. I realise mortality is "Eru's gift to Men", but isn't that just a marketing gimmick? I can see how immortality could have some advantages.
From Elrond's point of view I don't believe Arwen did the right thing. Sure, Aragorn's a great guy, and by marrying him she introduces Elven blood back into the rulers of Gondor. But Elrond probably thought she should have gone with her father, and he could find her a nice Elf guy in Valinor.
I think that from her own point of view though, Arwen did do the right thing. Ah, true love.
__________________
But Gwindor answered: 'The doom lies in yourself, not in your name'.
|