Okay.
Greenie was the seer.
Rikae was the hunter.
I'm innocent.
Inziladun was innocent.
McCaber and
Kath were innocent.
Boro and
Gwath are innocent.
Sally was a wolf.
Mac and
Shasta are wolves.
This is what I feel rather safe assuming. That leaves me the group:
Nerwen
Izzy
Eönwë
Mith
Mira
Eomer
Annu
Wilwa
Nogrod
with 1 wolf, 2 cobblers and 6 innocents in it.
Let's see.
Eomer and
Nerwen are not wolves, so the list of possible wolves goes down to:
Izzy
Eönwë
Mith
Mira
Annu
Wilwa
Nogrod
I think
Eönwë is not a wolf (given how
Mac treats him). If I have to bet, I will actually remove
Izzy and
Mith too, because they are more like ordos/cobblers than wolves.
So by my logic, the last wolf was someone who's already dead. Huzzah!
Then off to cobblers. The list of possible cobblers is:
Nerwen
Izzy
Eönwë
Mith
Mira
Eomer
Annu
Wilwa
Nogrod
I will take
Mira and
Wilwa off since they never gave me cobblerish vibes.
Nerwen's
Mac-vote exonerates her quite nicely yet not conclusively. Nah, if I have to guess the cobblers are/were among this three:
Nogrod,
Izzy and
Eomer.
DISCLAIMER: (
) this post is based on assumptions all of you don't want to make. It's not supposed to be a conclusive all in all answer to this mystery, it is just my take on it.
It seems like I've reached the conclusion that we only have two mutineers left. Unfortunately, I believe more in my chances of making a mistake than our chances to have done so well this far so I'm not getting hopeful yet.
And
Shasta, if we lynch
Mac and this game ends then, I will consider you innocent.
( = all people who seem more wolvish than
Shasta or at least as wolvish as him are dead already.)