[Macalaure]

I thought I'd better start a new post to reply to Lommy's big post about me. I expected to see some good points that I'd have to concede, plenty of bad points that I'd have to defend myself against. Instead, I would have to array one quote after the other and comment each with "what the heck?".

Seriously, Lommy, you're as far off as one can be.


Oh, darnit, let's try it anyway (all quotes by you-know-who)...

He pleasantly admitted it (that's what person of any role could do) and insisted he had added some points about people's activity.

For the love of... I made a list and you accused me of just agreeing in it. I definitely wasn't, and proved it by telling you that I considered ideas in there that nobody else had considered. Savvy?

And then he retaliated by (carefully friendlily jokingly) accusing me of being generic in return. Not too innocent especially as he was kindly not really suspecting me in return.

I retaliated with friendliness? Oh noes!!

I simply told you that your "points" against me were generic, and thus suspicious, but that your behaviour otherwise continued to make me feel innocent about you.

I accused him of agreeing with people too much and what does he say? "I disagreed with Nogrod on Day1."

That was not all I said, and you know it! Tell me how an innocent can quote this way to make her points?

An innocent would be more on guard about attacks against him because he would be annoyed by their untruthfulness.

But there was no untruthfulness in your attacks so far. There was nothing in your attacks so far. And that was exactly what I criticised.

I don't like his quarrel with Boro. It hardly looks like both of them are innocent.

This is another quite popular statement right now - one that nobody actually bothered to give reasons for. Parrots!

No one can honestly say that's not wolvish. Really, the way he takes it so jokingly and easily and smoothly just sets all my radars beeping.

Inconceivable! I replied jokingly to a joking accusation! String me up, please!


Reading over it again, it is actually a very finely crafted piece of demagogy. Now I have to make up my mind what's up with you. Mutineer, conspirator who's sure about an innocent, or completely misguided ordo. My problem is, I don't think a real mutineer would be so single-minded.

Let's read some more...