Quote:
Originally Posted by Kuruharan
That is an intriguing idea, and there is some evidence that might support it. I think by the time Sauron came to Eregion he had already been turned away by some of the other elves as seeming fair and feeling foul. In any event there were certainly some things to give one pause. Where exactly had this Annatar come from for one thing? Who was he really? Celebrimbor might well have had a better idea of who he was dealing with than he let on.
|
That's my take. Other elves got the sense that there was something wrong with Annatar, and so why not Celebrimbor? This person appears on the scene with no history (though if he made up one, I'd be interested in what Sauron said
)? At least Tom was known to be - exist - and had a track record. What were Annatar's bona fides - what allowed him to get so close to such an important elf?
I think that Celebrimbor 'played dumb,' even to Annatar (who may have suspected that he was suspected) in order to mine as much info from the maia as possible, hoping to turn the Gifty one out before things went sour.