Quote:
Originally Posted by William Cloud Hicklin
Why not just Haradrim? No Black Numenoreans or Men of Mordor are ever mentioned in the battle- the only cavalry was Southron.
|
Because their appearence differed. Because no scarlet banners were observed in the Morgul Vale. There were no reports of Haradrim marching to Minas Morgul, only to Morannon. The Host of Harad joined the army before Anduin crossing. And where ARE Men of Mordor after all?
I know these are no definite proofs, but these considerations give me pause.