Edited Wilwa adding Mith's votes:
Aragorn(8)
Boromir(15)
Éowyn(12)
Fingolfin(16)
Gimli(11)
Witch-King(6)
Eliminated
Haldir by mormegil
Frodo by Legate of Amon Lanc
Gothmog (non-balrog) by Oddwen
Gothmog(Balrog) by Rikae
The Chief Warg by Folwren
Samwise Gamgee by Wilwa
Sauron by Lommy
Gamling by mormegil
Hama by mormegil
Bombadil by Phantom
Now we are talking! Nice!
(okay x-ed, but does not matter

Simply, this is correct as well as the above.)