Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Brin
While I can't completely trust any of them, I will most certainly will be listening to what they have to say over you, a known baddie.
|
If you want to know what we think about
Izzy- here are my thoughts.
1) If
Izzy is indeed the Cobbler it would be remarkably convenient that
Rikae chose her as her target during her reveal.
2) But if
Izzy is indeed a WW, wasn't
Rikae even slightly worried that she would be believed and that
Izzy would be lynched, and the next day the WQ reveals with better proofs?
3) Unless she expected the WQ to reveal immediately, and thus "save"
Izzy from her fate and pretty much make
Izzy look clean.
4)
Izzy did not kick and scream about it as I believe an Ordo would, but that means nothing seeing as a Cobbler and a WW in on the plan would react similarly. For the Cobbler would know immediately that it was a false reveal (because they know they're not a WW), and they'd play along. But naturally a WW would too.
5) A given from my point of view, but not from anyone else's, is that I am a White Pawn, meaning that either
Mnem or
Wilwa must be evil. So it must be taken into account whether or not I believe either of them to be a Cobbler or WW.
6) I would more readily believe
Wilwa as a WW as opposed to a Cobbler, as I marked her early on a couple times for seeming to submarine through things. And though I can't remember her fully from past games, I think she's the sort that would act rather... crazy, as a Cobbler.
7) I have no clue whatsoever about
Mnem. I have no experience with her. Early on I gave her the Noob free pass (surely she wouldn't have a role in her first game etc), but I cannot overlook the fact that she's been a famous lurker on the Downs and in WW and our mod knew her before the game ever started.
8) At first reaction I might see
Wilwa as slightly more innocent than
Mnem, partly due to the fact that she seems to be the only one that trusts me. But as it is completely possible that she is buttering me up just to use me later, I really shouldn't allow that to sway me.
Finally-
9) As
Izzy is the only individual that is a
known baddie, I would likely guess in that direction on principle if it came down to it. It seems to me that at least killing a baddie (whatever they are) the final day is better than taking a chance on a baddie and failing. It would make me feel better anyway, as I have always cared rather more about my performance than the actual winning and losing (i.e. I'd rather play my best and lose than play like crap and get lucky and win- personal pride, ya know).