Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Fea
Durelin I think is downright evil, based on the fact that I think Brinn is right about who was dreamed of by Kath, and just yesterday Durelin spent all this time saying that Sally and the phantom were blacker than black. Either she was ironically oblivious, or Durelin was trying to cause trouble. If she guessed Kath was the seer (which if she's a wolf, it seems fair to assume, since the wolves killed Kath...), she might have wanted the village to kill off 'known' innocents before finding out they were known.
|
Really, is that a good enough reasoning alone to vote for
Dury? Just because some players caught onto
Kath doesn't mean everyone would've...and if everyone had, then
Kath would've been a rather poor seer, which I don't think she was. And for one thing, while I did have a slight suspicion that
Kath might be the seer, I didn't let my opinion be swayed based only on that reasoning. There were only a couple of things that made me think
Kath was seerish, one being her comment about not wanting to get Night killed (though really that could've been any non-ordo) and the comments she made about
Nogrod that I noticed only after his death. I didn't see her hints about
tp and
Sally being innocent until after her death because I didn't bother to look. Yes, I had a small suspicion that
Kath was seer, but usually I'm very wrong about these things and could've easily been again. It'd be a very bad idea to assume that just because she looks seerish that she is the seer, and therefore a bad idea to just assume that the other two were innocent as well. Because if I were wrong and she turned out evil, then my judgement of everyone else would be horribly off.
Anyway, what I'm trying to get to is that
Durelin could've really been completely oblivious to
Kath, or even if she did notice
Kath looked seerish doesn't mean she'd let her hinted dreams (which she may not have even caught onto) off the hook just because of that in case
Kath wasn't the seer. Of course it's possible that
Dury is in fact a baddie; I'm really not sure of what her role may be. But for
Fea to vote for her based only on that reason is very weak.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Durelin
Considering phantom bragged yesterDay about knowing who the seer was, this doesn't seem like a very good argument.
|
Oh yeah, I was going to ask
phantom:
So were you right all along about who the seer was?
Of course, to keep up his reputation I'm sure he'll answer yes regardless of whether he's telling the truth or not.
