Quote:
Originally Posted by Aganzir
Legate, for one time in your life you're funny. 
|
Thank you
But I hope that I won't play in that game of yours where you put in two Seers or such...
Quote:
Originally Posted by Brinniel
Anyways if I were a wraith, wouldn't I have chosen to make my life much easier by claiming I hadn't dreamt of her and she could either be a cobbler or wraith? I'm not choosing to make my claim look more doubtful. I dreamt of Lommy because in last several games we've played, she's managed to deceive me. Lommy is some who has a tendency to look innocentish and I wanted to be sure she wasn't a wraith.
|
I am not saying you could not have picked
Lommy, but if you are a Seer, it is lucky you picked her, when it was her who revealed you as a Wolf, while you were in fact the Seer.
Most of all, however, you had to say something now to react to
Lommy. You could have said you haven't dreamt of her, but that won't be of that much help: in either case, it will still be clear that one of you must be lying. And in that scenario, if
Lommy were lying, she would have been either a Wraith or a Cobbler, again, and it would be between the two of you, who are we going to believe. One reason I can think of why you named
Lommy was that maybe you haven't even given it thought into that depth and had to react. The other reason, more probable as it would be more clever, which I would expect from you more, could be that this way, you minimized "losses": you already had to name some people on your list to "fill in" - okay, you could have afforded to name one dead innocent, more would be probably a problem.
Rune could be either a fellow Wolf or an innocent you are trying to get to your side and making it seem logical (you and
Rune had a row, it would make sense if you tried to dream of him later).
Sally was done for, you decided to buy yourself another day, hoping that by burying
Sally, you get one day and who knows what may happen - toMorrow, it will still be between you and
Lommy, if she is alive. Now you had to fill in some last person into your list, which meant either writing another Wolf there, or an Innocent. Both is in its way uncomfortable. Writing a generally known person -
Lommy (who is either a Seer or now, by your claim, Ferny) - you would minimize losses.
But that's just my calculation on how it might be. You must know, and this is what I think, if you ask me. And it does not problematise not trusting you for me.