Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Boro
Or how about just both?
|
I have looked at both. But in the end, it's the
Menel voters I find more suspicious. The votes against
Noggie (heh, I almost wrote Noogie there) seem more reasonable to me. Of course, I know I'm biased because I voted
Nogrod myself. But it's probably in the same way you as a
Menel voter are biased.
So, the votes:
Cailin: ++Nogrod
First vote of the Day...her vote post was her only post, so I can't read from it. But it's not particularly suspicious.
Mac: ++Menel
Probably the least suspicious of the
Menel voters. His suspicions of him came from the beginning. He voted so early, I doubt he was expecting any sort of bandwagon to occur.
Gwath: ++Nogrod
The two did have a brief scuffle earlier in the Day, so his vote doesn't exactly surprise me. On Day 1 when there aren't strong candidates, any sort of negative interaction with a player can result in a lynch vote.
Shasta: ++tgwbs
Came out of the blue, no explanation. I'd like to hear one when he shows up.
tgwbs: ++Fea
In the post before, he said he wouldn't vote her. And then he does. Why the Legate 180? (yes I'm still using that phrase
)
Lariren: ++Ilya
Vote is based on a hunch. Not a strong reasoning, but common for Day One. I'm not worried about her vote.
Fea: ++Menel
Says there's no one else she wants to lynch. Not exactly strong reasoning.
Boro: ++Mac
Says earlier that he doesn't like
Mac's vote for
Menel.
Brinn: ++Nogrod
Best option of those who already received a vote, plus as I mentioned,
Menel was being talked about and I didn't want him lynched. Honestly, I don't think I had great reason behind my vote and on Day 1; I never do. I often do get suspected for my vote and hey, I can't really blame you people...so I won't argue it too much.
Kath: ++Ilya
Seems to suspect her consistently, so nothing unusual jumps out to me.
Sally: ++Nogrod
Of the
Nogrod votes, it is her's that looks most bandwaggonish, I think. What I find interesting is that she joins the "suspect
Menel" bandwagon earlier and puts him highest on her lynch list, yet votes
Nogrod. I can't help but wonder if she did this to make herself look good (by saying she's voting him to prevent a double lynch).
Ilya: ++Strongbow
Based on feeling, his posts seem abrasive. Her vote doesn't have strong reasoning, but that's not what worries me. She spread out the votes even more at a critical time which seems rather safe.
Boromir: --Mac/++Menel
Sort of indicates he'll make an explanation later, though he hasn't yet. I find it very interesting that he originally voted
Mac for his
Menel vote, then he changes his vote to
Menel himself. No explanation, but my guess is to "save"
Nogrod.
Aganzir: ++Nogrod
She suspected him all Day, so her vote is no surprise.
tgwbs: --Fea/++Menel
Another "save"
Nogrod vote I'm guessing?
Sally: --Nogrod/++Menel
Tried and failed to prevent a double lynch from occurring. Looks pretty innocent, but then again she could be trying to make herself look good.
Non voters:
Strongbow: Seems to have missed the deadline, which happens.
Gollum: Was there at deadline, but chose not to vote due to lack of time. Choosing not to vote is one thing, and if it's a one-time thing I don't mind. But he abstained at a critical time when it looked like a double lynch was possible...I don't care who he would've voted for, he had the opportunity to prevent the double lynch and he didn't do anything.
About this whole "save
Nogrod" thing...
It seems that came up when his whole divo comment was brought up via secret code talk. Did you quts really think
Noggie was the divo? I don't think he'd be so obvious. It seems to me that this whole discussion which resulted in a switch of votes to
Menel was just another ploy. Probably someone has intentions behind the ploy to misguide the wolves, but at the same time I think it's just as likely someone else has intentions to misguide everyone else. So the people who were involved:
tp
Fea
Boro
tgwbs
...Might be innocent or might be guilty. Whatever they are, I'll be watching them...with the exception of
tp, for obvious reasons.
So based on votes, in order of suspicious to least suspicious:
tgwbs
Boro
Ilya
Sally
Fea
Gollum
Shasta
Kath
Lariren
Aganzir
Mac
Cailin
Gwath
Strongbow
Also, I must mention I did a double take on
Cailin's post toDay because at first I thought it was
Shasta which made me really confused. Apparently their avatars are very similar in colour. So apologies if I mix you two up again. But goodness, I should've figured it out immediately what with the
Eomer references.
Btw, while I was writing this post I got interrupted by Grey's Anatomy, and on top that I have a headache. I can't even remember everything I wrote I wrote in this post or whether I'm forgetting something I meant to say. And I'm sure I'll x-post with many others, but I don't feel well enough to care..