The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum - View Single Post - Tol-in-Gaurhoth LIV: The Council of Evil

satansaloser2005 · 12-30-2008, 12:45 PM

Day One

Okay, so the first 'accusation' of any kind is toward Gwath, saying that he's too tough on Bowie. But this was on the first Day, so while he may be right he couldn't possibly know for sure, as he had no 'pre-game' dream, poor fellow.

Then he mentions Agan, dedicates quite a post toward her, and says that she looks pretty dern suspicious because she's after Gwath, that and her suspicion of Brinniel and all this business. He also accuses her of flip flopping, but not in so many words.

Find Ilya a bit suspicious, and says that Gwath sounds suspicious no matter what he is, but votes Agan.

Day Two

But then, oh, then, he mentions Agan again. And if I'm not mistaken the gist of his post is "oh, just kidding, I read her wrong, I think she's innocent but I'll still keep an eye on her because I should". It makes me thinks that he possibly dreamt her innocent. In the same post he mentions Gwath and Bowie as possible partners.

He then votes Gwath, well after the deadline but a vote nonetheless, and there were other candidates up (including myself and Agan, though Ilya was basically dead anyway so it was a throwaway of sorts) so I wonder if he did indeed dream Gwath.

Thus, his possible dreams for the night of Boro's death, at least that would make sense with what he's posted: Agan (innocent/hunter) or Gwath (wolf/bear).

The next Day he starts off his posting by noting the dead, our beloved and departed Boro and Nog. Who could do such a thing? Perhaps Kath, he suggests. She is a tricksy one, after all.

In the next post he says he's gone through Kath's posts and there's not much to talk about, but he finds nothing that 'jumps out as suspicious'. That doesn't mean that he doesn't suspect her, only that he doesn't see anything in her posts that is suspicious. Perhaps he's dreamt her?

Yay! He called me evil!

Anyway, moving on. I was on the chopping block that day so since he didn't vote me I doubt he dreamt me. (And even if he did dream me....well, then he definitely wouldn't have voted me because I'm innocent, but I'm the only one who knows that so I won't take that into account.) If you're Miss Paranoid Agan Pants

and assume that I'm evil, it could be a bluff by not voting me to keep him alive long enough to find my partner. I'll put the theory out there, even though it's not true. Also, he still finds Gwath and Bowie suspicious, but votes Bowie because he's overdefensive. Perhaps he'd dreamt Gwath already (whether this night or the night previous) and wanted to get rid of a possible unknown wolf? Then upon the dawn he could tell us that Gwath was the other furry fiend and we'd be rid of both of them and just left with the bear.

Thus....possible dreams: Kath (wolf/bear), Sally (wolf/bear), Gwath....again (wolf/bear)

He never mentions anyone but the five of us though. He talks of how we react to the other players, but never mentioned Eon, Shasta, Izzy, or any of the dead players in his suspicions. (Edit to this: that's not true, after I saw the Agan vote post. He also mentions Ilya, but the fact remains that he speaks of Gwath the most after Day One, along with Kath, Agan, and I. I'm not counting Bowie because he's dead.)

My theory? His dreams were either Agan (innocent/hunter) and Gwath (wolf/bear), Agan (innocent/hunter) and Kath (wolf/bear), or Gwath (wolf/bear) and Kath (wolf/bear).

So....Agan, my dear, it seems to be up to us (if you're trusting me again, which I doubt). Gwath or Kath? I'm assuming Gwath because Kath is hardly going to vote for herself and if Agan votes me then we definitely wouldn't get a wolf. At the same time, however, I feel rather unsports(wo)manlike killing Gwath while he's gone. But still.

12-30-2008, 12:45 PM	#253
satansaloser2005 The Sweetest Spoiler Join Date: Nov 2007 Location: from beneath you it giggles incessantly Posts: 5,789	*Day One* Okay, so the first 'accusation' of any kind is toward Gwath, saying that he's too tough on Bowie. But this was on the first Day, so while he may be right he couldn't possibly know for sure, as he had no 'pre-game' dream, poor fellow. Then he mentions Agan, dedicates quite a post toward her, and says that she looks pretty dern suspicious because she's after Gwath, that and her suspicion of Brinniel and all this business. He also accuses her of flip flopping, but not in so many words. Find Ilya a bit suspicious, and says that Gwath sounds suspicious no matter what he is, but votes Agan. *Day Two* But then, oh, then, he mentions Agan again. And if I'm not mistaken the gist of his post is "oh, just kidding, I read her wrong, I think she's innocent but I'll still keep an eye on her because I should". It makes me thinks that he possibly dreamt her innocent. In the same post he mentions Gwath and Bowie as possible partners. He then votes Gwath, well after the deadline but a vote nonetheless, and there were other candidates up (including myself and Agan, though Ilya was basically dead anyway so it was a throwaway of sorts) so I wonder if he did indeed dream Gwath. Thus, his possible dreams for the night of Boro's death, at least that would make sense with what he's posted: Agan (innocent/hunter) or Gwath (wolf/bear). The next Day he starts off his posting by noting the dead, our beloved and departed Boro and Nog. Who could do such a thing? Perhaps Kath, he suggests. She is a tricksy one, after all. In the next post he says he's gone through Kath's posts and there's not much to talk about, but he finds nothing that 'jumps out as suspicious'. That doesn't mean that he doesn't suspect her, only that he doesn't see anything in her posts that is suspicious. Perhaps he's dreamt her? Yay! He called me evil! Anyway, moving on. I was on the chopping block that day so since he didn't vote me I doubt he dreamt me. (And even if he did dream me....well, then he definitely wouldn't have voted me because I'm innocent, but I'm the only one who knows that so I won't take that into account.) If you're Miss Paranoid Agan Pants and assume that I'm evil, it could be a bluff by not voting me to keep him alive long enough to find my partner. I'll put the theory out there, even though it's not true. Also, he still finds Gwath and Bowie suspicious, but votes Bowie because he's overdefensive. Perhaps he'd dreamt Gwath already (whether this night or the night previous) and wanted to get rid of a possible unknown wolf? Then upon the dawn he could tell us that Gwath was the other furry fiend and we'd be rid of both of them and just left with the bear. Thus....possible dreams: Kath (wolf/bear), Sally (wolf/bear), Gwath....again (wolf/bear) He never mentions anyone but the five of us though. He talks of how we react to the other players, but never mentioned Eon, Shasta, Izzy, or any of the dead players in his suspicions. (Edit to this: that's not true, after I saw the Agan vote post. He also mentions Ilya, but the fact remains that he speaks of Gwath the most after Day One, along with Kath, Agan, and I. I'm not counting Bowie because he's dead.) My theory? His dreams were either Agan (innocent/hunter) and Gwath (wolf/bear), Agan (innocent/hunter) and Kath (wolf/bear), or Gwath (wolf/bear) and Kath (wolf/bear). So....Agan, my dear, it seems to be up to us (if you're trusting me again, which I doubt). Gwath or Kath? I'm assuming Gwath because Kath is hardly going to vote for herself and if Agan votes me then we definitely wouldn't get a wolf. At the same time, however, I feel rather unsports(wo)manlike killing Gwath while he's gone. But still. __________________ "My heart always cowers behind the defense of my wit." Friendship is two pals munching on a well-cooked face together. Fenris bookworm.