[Kath]

Gwath, here is what I posted about you yesterDay:

Day 1 has some very short posts, some controversy over considering voting for himself and voted Nogrod. Was mentioned by Nog - 'maybe we should not judge too heavily at this moment but he does look evasive indeed'. Potentially a wolf buddy 'ooh look but don't actually' moment. Argumentative with Legate - poking at his suspicions of Agan and questioning his vote for phantom. The second comment against Legate is odd ... it seems more misunderstanding than anything else but the tone is very accusing. Nog then voted to lynch him. What I can't recall is whether there was any other support for Gwath being lynched Day 1. If there was then it seems unlikely he and Nog were wolf buddies, if there wasn't then it's a pretty safe vote and that likelihood goes up.
Day 2 I do not get his reasoning for assuming Nog innocent. Joins the 'why must you have secret ploys' brigade. Fails to vote.
Day 3 - says Eonwe's list isn't useful because his suspicions sound the same - I have to say I disagree but that's personal opinion. Pushing idea of phantom and Boro both being wolves. Seemed almost behind the times - 'maybe the Seer has dreamt of one of you already' when that was the angle that phantom had been pushing for ages. Hmm, mentions Nog again ... sort of defending him. Despite suggesting that Boro and phantom may both be wolves he then votes Boro as his Rep and also says he doesn't want to get rid of him yet ... which if we can believe what our wolves were saying yesterDay was a major part of their discussions during the Night, perhaps this is a Daytime message along the same lines. Says odd reasoning to vote Ka ... which is just what morm says a bit later.
Day 4 - surprised that Ka is a wolf. Could go either way that one really. Overly confused by Boro's revelation. Turns against Nog ... saving his own skin? Votes Nerwen as meant to. Hasn't said anything so far toDay I don't think.

Now there are a few questions or at least things you could answer in there I think. Such as telling us whether or not there was any other support for lynching you Day 1. Re-explaining why you thought Nog innocent Day 2 because I really didn't understand that. Why, having suggested that Boro might be a wolf, you then went and voted him Rep. Why you said you'd come back and interact with people so that we could get a better view of you and then kinda didn't. Why you seemed convinced that there would be a toMorrow if sally was lynched instead of you. There may be some other things, it's up to you if you want to do a really comprehensive defense or just basically answer the questions.

I want to lynch a wolf. I don't want a situation like yesterDay where Nerwen was so determined that sally was a wolf that even when sally defended herself fairly Nerwen couldn't see it. I will keep an open mind Gwath, I want to hear what you have to say.

Anyway, I have to go so it's voting time. Rep voting toDay might have to be a matter of deduction.

Alive are:
Brinniel - no because I can get no clear read on her. In fact toMorrow I am going to go through her posts and find out why that is.
Gil-Galad - no, for obvious reasons.
Greenie - no because it worries me that my suspicion of her has faded as quickly as it appeared. I want to try and find out what startled me.
Gwathagor - no because I suspect him.
Ilya
Lommy
Nerwen - no because I didn't like the way she attacked sally at the end of yesterDay. I know I've been doing something similar with Gwath. Having seen the results of that kind of behaviour I am trying to pull myself back.
Rune

Which leaves Ilya, Lommy and Rune. Actually Rune is another one I really want to look at so not him ... and I think I'm more confident about Lommy than Ilya so:

++LOMMY for Rep