My
Eönwë case from day 1.
During the later part of day 1
Eönwë said he was going to make a list of reps who got voted seemingly out of nowhere. It took him a day, but at least he did it now.
He agreed with
Greenie who complained about favouring loud players and talked about the advantages of being quiet. However, although quiet players may come up with things as well as loud ones, and although everybody doesn't have to make dozens of posts a day, posting at least about your initial suspicions helps also others. Yes, the main aim of werewolf is to catch the baddies without being caught yourself, but the way the wolves are caught is talking. I don't care how much a player talks, but I'd rather they posted more serious talk than jokes and banter.
Here are
Eönwë's answers for some questions I asked in my earlier case, and
here my comments on them.
Eönwë, why wouldn't you have voted
Brinn? I just see you didn't reply to it last time.
Eönwë doesn't talk about people very much - jokes randomly more than accuses. He cast a bit suspicion against me, though, after I had said I didn't have a proper case against
Legate yet voted him anyway, and asked why I didn't try to lynch someone I suspected. The problem was I wasn't sure about anyone. He also speculated I put it out in the open just so anyone couldn't accuse me of hiding something.
I think that was quite a daring move from
Eönwë given that besides
Legate he was my other voting option back then. I'm not sure how easy it would be for me to imagine an
Eönwolf questioning me after I had suspected him pretty much earlier.
He voted
Lommy for rep, promising to explain his vote and suspicions in the second half. According to him, most people he wanted for his rep wanted him dead. Who were these people,
Eönwë? He also said he wouldn't be doing his service for the village if he was lynched instead of a wolf. I can give you a piece of advice (and I hope it doesn't sound like I was pressurizing you into it): I think if you posted more about your actual suspicions instead of just showing up, people might find it easier to trust you.
He could apparently have voted also for
phantom or
Boro, but didn't think they would need any extra votes. Well phantom didn't become a rep today, so better not count on that.
Then there's this post concerning those who got to be reps despite posting little, which he promised to do yesterday. I found it a bit weird and out of nowhere at first, but when I actually read he had promised to make it, it didn't feel that strange anymore. He's right when saying that
Brinn's posts aren't enough to see if she's innocent or not, but I already told I didn't mind it that much. All in all, although yesterday's rep voting begins to be a bit old issue already, there's nothing wrong with the post in my opinion.
I am feeling better also about
Eönwë now, and there's yet another person I'm unlikely to vote today. He's a bit weird at times, but mostly he comes across as pretty genuine.
edit: xed since my last post