Quote:
Originally Posted by Gothbogg the Ripper
Wow, I pop my head out of the gutter and what should I see? An old thread of mine risen from the dead!
|
I'd been meaning to state this about Tom, but, as usual, had other things to do first.
Quote:
And that's all well and good, but in a film it would be nothing but noise for the sake of noise.
Especially as the power of nature is already well represented by Treebeard and his little massacre at Isengard.
|
I never took Tom and Goldberrry as a sop to the power of nature but more of 'how weird and wonderful this new world of Middle Earth is.' Some stories are so tight that one begins to think that nothing happens by chance, at random, or that does not lead to some big revelation at the end.
Tom is completely unnecessary, like whipped cream on pineapple upside-down cake, but all the better for it.
So Peter Jackson wisely left Tom out. Though, as a secret bonus track on RotK, he could have filmed and added the Tom sequence, if just to say 'thanks' to the fans (and to make up for TTT).
