Quote:
Originally Posted by Gwathagor
Perhaps the Numenorean people should never have existed at all; one could consider them a failed experiment on the part of the Valar, a phenomenon that defied went against too many facts of reality and that was, at its core, wrong. It had gone well at first, but eventually it became clear that Men were not meant to live in such privilege, so close to the Valar, with gifts of knowledge, strength, health, and the ability to die when they saw fit. It might seem callous or simplistic to just take the Numenoreans as a whole race, rather than on an individual basis, but this approach would be consistent with Tolkien's style of dealing with race in LOTR: he frequent relies on generalities. The Numenoreans had run their course, which really never should have been. In this light, Eru appears merciful for allowing a few of this problematic people group, this aberration, to continue.
(I've never thought about it this way before, and I haven't even entirely convinced myself yet - but I'm entertaining the notion.)
|
This has made me think about the rights and wrongs of what the Valar did.
The Valar were quite cruel, providing Men with this island from which could be seen a tiny little glimpse of the Undying Lands, a place where the people are immortals. Not only that, but creating a place of near-perfection which only lacked that one ingredient which allowed the Men there to enjoy this paradise in eternity. Back in the 'real world', i.e. Middle-earth, life was still relatively gritty (even more so once the Edain upped sticks and abandoned the rest of the Men to their fate), but on Numenor it was great - just that they could only enjoy this 'jolly' of a life for a limited time.
Yet Eru had made Men in their nature mortals, and had made them that way because Eru saw their mortality as a
gift. The Valar did not go against this, they
could not change that, but they certainly tampered with it.
What happened in Numenor also gives you some background on why in later years the Elves tried to keep away from Men. It was quite possibly for the
benefit of Men, not to torment them with this one thing they could not have.
I wouldn't say it was
merciful for Eru to cause the cataclysm which sent Numenor to the watery depths, but it could certainly be argued that it was necessary for him to take the Undying Lands away from the sight of Men,
for their own good.