Hmmm... I reread the thread and I don't really suspect anyone enough that I would be comfortable with voting them. That's why I'd feel the most comfortable with voting someone who has contributed only a little. I would pardon
Brinn and
Kath for RL reasons, and
Gaunt for newbieishness.
Diamond and
Groin haven't probably realised this game is going on - even though I did see
Groin in "who's online" an hour or two ago and sent him a PM that he should be invisible as the game has started... but yes, I'd "pardon" them too. That kind of leaves
Shasta...
edit: xed with Gwath (yay he's back!) and Eomer